Entry details

Younghusband
Author

Younghusband

Date

January 4th, 2010

Tags

,

Comments

11 Comments so far.
Add yours.

Solving Afghanistan, one PPT slide at a time

Afghanistan: A complex problem made even more so

Look at this powerpoint slide! I haven’t seen that many arrows since Agincourt. From Marginal revolution:

It’s all in this military powerpoint, apparently official.  On the positive side they are aware the problem is complex.

In the Novum Organum, published in 1620, Francis Bacon presented his idea of scientific method. In it he lists four “idols of the mind” which hinder correct scientific reasoning. I think Powerpoint should be promoted as a new idol.

Despite its complexity, it is worth reading through the entire document to see how they reached this particular slide. But in no way can I imagine calling this a “model” of dynamics. It is more like a link analysis of To Do’s.

h/t to Joe. Also see: Present Arms! The military and Powerpoint.

Comments to this entry

Curzon
January 4, 2010
7:01 am
"I haven’t seen that many arrows since Agincourt."

Very nice.
Peter Hodge
January 4, 2010
8:27 am
I love that quip...
Sperweractual
January 4, 2010
12:42 pm
Were you @ Agincourt, too? I was next in line to George Patton.
Jeffrey Sykes
January 4, 2010
7:11 pm
I'm enjoying this blog very much. Loved the Agincourt quip.

I was the archer two rows behind Patton.
Joe Jones
January 5, 2010
1:08 am
The major sin of this slide is that it steals the viewer's attention as they try to follow all the spaghetti lines around. This is a great graphic, but it should be printed out on tabloid or A3-sized paper and hung by someone's desk for quiet contemplation, not hauled out in the middle of a speech to distract people.
Tweets that mention ComingAnarchy.com » Solving Afghanistan, one PPT slide at a time -- Topsy.com
January 5, 2010
3:43 am
[...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Peter Durfee, Quiet Babylon Feeds. Quiet Babylon Feeds said: News: Solving Afghanistan, one PPT slide at a time http://bit.ly/4QVsLj [...]
SJPONeill
January 5, 2010
7:16 pm
Row 7, #237 here

"I haven’t seen that many arrows since Agincourt."

Great line!!
I haven’t seen that many arrows since Agincourt « The World According to Me…
January 5, 2010
8:10 pm
[...] } What a great line!! Coming Anarchy a couple of days ago offers some insight into the military’s subservience to the Great God of [...]
Manage is a good word « The World According to Me…
January 7, 2010
8:06 pm
[...] that we are still not getting into this (after EIGHT years of war!!) might be those alluded to here on Coming Anarchy, or more specifically, this Wikipedia page referenced in the CA article. I’d never heard of [...]
Beauty
January 7, 2010
11:37 pm
"These projects are complex, large-scale and take place in resource poor geographies with challenging operational circumstances. PA Consulting Group is recognized regularly for its ability to plan, organise and manage these types of projects successfully and is committed to employing its skills and experience to help transform people's lives." You must be joking! The complexity of this work in progress (wip) ppt is a reason Afghanistan is likely to stay under as dark a cloud as other conflict zones managed by He-Man and MOTU. Yes, a work of art but what is it hiding?
Link(s) der Woche (KW 3) « Babbel-Net
January 19, 2010
3:57 pm
[...] Solving Afghanistan, One PPT Slide At A Time – Wer schon immer der Meinung war, dass Präsentationen in Powerpoint oft zu oberflächlich sind, sollte einen Blick auf diese kleine Übersicht zum Afghanistankonflikt und seinen momentanen Problemen werfen. Hier sieht man zumindest dass nicht jeder Ami in Führungspositionen dies für eine leicht zu lösende Angelegenheit hält. [...]