Entry details

MF
Author

Munro Ferguson

Date

August 26th, 2009

Tags

Comments

17 Comments so far.
Add yours.

Clowns to the left of me, jokers to the right…

This post could be subtitled: Why I find American politics tedious.

I steer clear of online political forums, read very few blatantly partisan blogs (though the few that do rest in my rss reader are excellent) and typically flip past cable news programs of a political bent. It isn’t that I don’t appreciate domestic politics or find political discussion boring in and of itself. It’s the noise.

The keening, shrill, oft juvenile shrieking that pours forth from the lunatic fringe of both political proclivities, left and right. This fringe may well entail a minority in the American body politic but what they lack in numbers they make up for in pure, shouting volume. Common sense, critical debate and any semblance of reality are drowned out in a crescendo of hysterical and vapid bush_hitlerscalednonsense that starts with [choose your partisan radio/television savant] and is passed along to a herd of willing recipients who re-manufacture the whole mess on a smaller scale (the political forums I mentioned, public speaking events, protests, etc.)

One of the more insidious aspects of this irritating and loud minority is the ease in which they draw hackneyed comparisons between their enemy du jour and history’s darkest ideologies, institutions and tyrants. The more proliferate example of this idiocy these days can be found regarding both the previous and current administrations and the evocation of history’s most tragically successful sociopath, Adolf Hitler. During the Bush administration it was all the rage among left wing anti-warriors with a whole lot of energy and very little sense.

Most recently the ignorant comparison has been attributed to right wing simpletons who’ve taken the leftward swing of American domestic policy under President Barack Obama and followed their left wing cousins of yore:

ObamaHitler

The logic used to support this position is childlike in it’s simplicity. Hitler’s Nazi party was officially called the National Socialist German Workers Party. You see, it’s got “socialist” in it and so if Obama’s left wing policies are tantamount to a national shift toward socialism (which they are cuz Sean Hannity sez so) and the Nazis described their party as socialist, well say no more.

The conclusion is easy.  Forget all that historical context of the rise and fall of fascism; hyper-nationalism, anti-semitism, anti-communism, expansionism, etc.  If it walks like a duck and talks like a duck it must be a Nazi.

I understand that mud slinging and politics go hand in hand but, really, it’s gotten to the point of absurdity.

Comments to this entry

Posts about Barack Obama as of August 25, 2009 » The Daily Parr
August 26, 2009
1:00 am
[...] illness with you-know-who One single payer system everybody gets their share But well never have Clowns to the left of me, jokers to the right… - cominganarchy.com 08/26/2009 This post could be subtitled: Why I find American politics tedious. [...]
Roger Yang
August 26, 2009
1:01 am
Well, I'm pretty sure that Nazis in this day in age can be applied anywhere and everywhere. Unfortunately. Though it seems somewhat annoying that Socialism is almost a curse word at this point.
cirby
August 26, 2009
2:54 am
One tiny little problem, though.

It seems that pretty much all of the recent "Nazi" comments about Obama have come from either Ron Paul supporters like the guy in the photo above (not exactly hard-core right-wingers, or right-wingers at all, really) or from Obama supporters pretending to be right-wingers. As it is, the number of actual right-wingers using that sort of imagery are practically nonexistent when compared to the mainstream left-wing usage of the symbol during the last eight years. On a related note, police arrested a young man in Denver for vandalizing the windows of a Democratic office. Guess which party he was associated with.

Sure, there have been "Socialist=National Socialist" retorts from the right, but that's mostly in response to the less-sane Democrats who have been doing the "Bushitler" call-out for the last eight years. This is also more than balanced out by the recent habit of leftists to claim that pretty much every useful thing in society is a "socialist" policy, from streets to firefighters.

What current Democrats have (mildly) in common with the early 20th century fascists is a moderate penchant for "cult of personality" movements, and the Obama trend is just another one of those. The good part is that they tend to fall heavily for one or another of those guys, and fall right back out of their infatuation about a year after they shove him into office. Carter ("such a nice man!"), Clinton ("so cool!"), and now Obama ("Hope and Change!"). They're still in the middle-denial stage with Obama, though. Give them another year, and instead of blind support, you'll get "well, sure, we know he's in over his head, but at least he's not Bush!" Ten years down the road, it'll be "look at all of the good he did!" Thirty years down the road, and it'll be "well, he tried to do the right thing, none of those disasters were his actual fault..."
Peter
August 26, 2009
7:35 am
Godwin's Law, folks. Unless we're really discussing someone burning other people, Godwin's Law.
Michael Turton
August 26, 2009
10:01 am
Yes, clearly the Left was shrilly insane to argue that a President who put the US into criminal invasions of prostrate foreign nations that resulted in hundreds of thousands dead and injured, engaged in widespread domestic spying, implemented illegal torture and murder interrogations, implemented an extralegal torture-n-kidnapping program, employed mercenaries in assassination programs, persecuted domestic dissidents through the Patriot Act and No-Fly list, used the terror alert system to make political hay (by definition of terrorism is the use of terror for political gain), and of course, trashed the environment and economy, made zero progress on global warming, and generally debased the United States in all possible ways, was a fascist. Nobody rational would ever see fascism in any of those actions. You'd have to be nuts...
Alfred Russel Wallace
August 26, 2009
12:24 pm
Mr Turton - perhaps we agree that one doesn't necessarily see fascism in those actions - it was stupid, venal greed. Greed for power, greed for influence, and in the long run, greed for wealth by looting our treasury. Little is gained by calling it fascism - it diverts attention from the facts, which are quite ugly enough.
Gollios
August 26, 2009
1:56 pm
This post reminded me of this: http://stuffwhitepeoplelike.com/2008/06/25/winner-4/
Master Cook
August 26, 2009
4:14 pm
False equivalence between the American left and American right.

How many liberals are bringing guns to public meetings? Or arguing in favor of torture?
Chief Wiggum
August 26, 2009
5:25 pm
"How many liberals are bringing guns to public meetings?"

http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/32525040/ns/local_news-phoenix_az/

"...The man would only give his first name as he stood alone, wearing a Yankee baseball team shirt, a handgun on his hip, holding a contrary sign.

Josh, who explained he would only give his first name because of the type of work he does, said he was a Democrat among a sea of non-Democrats, touting health care reform, but not reforms over his right to bear arms.

"Part of my passion as a Democrat is the right to bear arms," Josh said.

A veteran, and from a long family history of veterans, the man who was very much alone in the small crowd of protesters said he believed in fighting for the less fortunate.

"I am a firm supporter of health care for every American," he said."

____

According to MSNBC, the sign the guy was displaying had a picture of Obama with a Hitler mustache. What this all means, I have no idea.
Twitter Trackbacks for ComingAnarchy.com » Clowns to the left of me, jokers to the right… [cominganarchy.com] on Topsy.com
August 26, 2009
7:04 pm
[...] link is being shared on Twitter right now. @anaya_midz said ComingAnarchy.com » Clowns to the left of [...]
Sejo
August 26, 2009
8:16 pm
Oh well, Chief Wiggum, I suppose Rome's last years were like this.
Rommel
August 26, 2009
9:53 pm
Rome did have trouble with illegal immigrants toward the end..
Michael
August 27, 2009
5:47 am
I was at that rally where that picture of the man holding the Obama-Hitler photo was taken. That man was most definitly not Right wing, most of the people there with that group were actaully black (much to my surprise). Many people (Right wingers) asked them to leave. They are there for their own reasons, whatever they may be.
Michael
August 27, 2009
6:01 am
I am sorry I was wrong, afte examining the picture closer and observing no leaves on the trees that must have been from a rally earlyer in the year. I was at a rally there last week. Anyhow those people are involved with Lyndon LaRouche.
tehag
August 28, 2009
12:07 pm
It got silly when Eisenhower was described as a dedicated member of the Communist Conspiracy. It got silly when LBJ was described as a fascist. It got silly when Ezra Pound (among others) said that FDR was implementing Mussolini's policies.

If 'Nazi' and 'Communist' are the worst insults in the political sphere, of course people will use them inappropriately.

tehag
Skippy-san
August 29, 2009
4:18 pm
Great post! In five paragraphs you have summed up the lunatic world we live in........

Howard Beale lives!
JackUH
September 6, 2009
5:02 am
@Cirby

Oh c'mon Cirby. Your selective bias is showing. Republicans are as prone to having "personality cults" (I prefer the more flattering "statesman" moniker though) as Dems are. How many times has the right mentioned Reagan and attempting to find another one of him? Eisenhower too had his followers to a lesser extent. And Dems have also had less than inspiring presidents like Harry Truman and LBJ. Truman though has had a small resurgence for desegregation of the US military and ending World War 2.