Entry details

Younghusband
Author

Younghusband

Date

December 1st, 2008

Tags

, , ,

Comments

3 Comments so far.
Add yours.

The Kaplan View of Mumbai

Robert Kaplan just spent a month in Gujarat reporting on Hindu-Muslim relations (does trouble follow this guy or what?). He has a few brief words on the terrorist attacks in Mumbai. Kaplan argues that “India has more to lose from extremist Islam than arguably any other country in the world” and that despite the terrorist’s call to history “this is not an ancient historical divide so much as a recreated modern one.” Some “rudimentary” background from Kaplan:

The Mumbai terrorists announced themselves as the Deccan Mujahideen. The Deccan is a rugged plateau region in south-central India that Aurangzeb, the fierce Sunni emperor of the Mughals (India’s most historically significant Muslim dynasty) could never subdue and in fact died trying in 1707. The Islamic Mughals vanquished all of northern India, Pakistan, and a good part of Afghanistan, but they could never consolidate the Deccan against the Hindu Maratha warriors.

Comments to this entry

kurt9
December 1, 2008
9:12 pm
The Indians may start to support certain factions in Afghanistan, just to keep Pakistan's government off balance. Of course, the Pakistan government itself is battling Pushto tribes in the Northwest Pakistan area. Perhaps the attacks in Mumbai were an attempt to distract the Pakistan government in their attempts to pacify the Pushto area by trying to provoke a confrontation between the Pakistan government and India. If this is indeed the strategy, it would be reasonable to expect another attack in India. Perhaps this next one will be in New Delhi or some other major Indian city.

This, in turn, will cause escalation. The Indians are not the calmest of people and they will want to retaliate. This, in turn, will stir up the Pakistan government as well as Muslims in both India as well as Pakistan. Perhaps the Pakistan government will be overthrown because they are not doing enough to defend the country as well as the honor of Islam!

It almost happened in 2002. We may yet see a nuclear war on FoxNews and CNN. I wonder if they will send Geraldo Rivera in to cover it.
Curzon
December 2, 2008
4:17 am
Another blog post:
http://www.getreligion.org/?p=4178
ComingAnarchy.com » Blog Archive » “…a child’s messy finger painting…”
December 11, 2008
4:01 pm
[...] Kaplan gave a brief outlook of the terrorist attacks in Mumbai in The Atlantic last month. He followed up those brief thoughts [...]