There has been a round of religiously motivated censorship recently that I would like to draw everyone’s attention to.
First is the anti-Koran film Fitna which was pulled from LiveLeak due to threats according to the Underwire. Dan originally had the film embedded on his site when he talked about it a couple of days ago. You can still see a copy at Google Video.
Then of course is our favourite religious corporate organization, the Church of Scientology. They sued to stop the distribution of The Profit, a fictional film about a religious group that resembles the Co$. This event happened a few years ago but illegal distribution is still going on and the controversy is still active as of three days ago. Anti-Co$ hacker network Anonymous drew everyone’s attention to the film again recently. You can get the torrent at TPB (h/t DtB).
Lastly there is the PZ Myers episode last week of being expelled from Expelled. PZ is a biology prof and evolution blogger. Expelled is a creationist “documentary” about how “Big Science” shuts out the dissenting views on evolution. PZ went to a showing, was recognized while standing in line and kicked out of the theater. His three guests got in though, one of which was … wait for it … this dude! PZ blogged the incident and epic lulz ensued.
What to make of all this? Hey, the religious orgs are doing what they do: shutting people up and trying to control the message. Whether it involves litigation or violence, organized religion wants to build boundaries around the minds of believers and non-believers alike. The sad thing is that they have been surprisingly successful. However, I think this just makes them look worse in the end. I can’t wait for the day when transparency and rationality reign.
- BROWSE / IN TIMELINE
- « Equal Alliance, Unequal Roles
- » Here comes Season 2!
COMMENTS / 8 COMMENTS
P.Z. Myers Trojan Horse for Godless Dawkins « KuiperCliff added these pithy words on Mar 31 08 at 8:21 am[...] Trojan Horse for Godless Dawkins Posted on 31 March 2008 by kuipercliff I just saw this on Coming Anarchy and I laughed so hard it deserves to be passed on. We all know who P.Z. Myers is, as did those [...]
Chief Wiggum added these pithy words on 29 Mar 08 at 5:02 amIf enough people pray for transparency and rationality, it will happen.
KuiperCliff added these pithy words on 31 Mar 08 at 8:13 amThat story about Dawkins is priceless! Laughing hard, laughing hard.
Aceface added these pithy words on 01 Apr 08 at 4:47 amAdd some new one.
The screening of documentary “YASUKUNI” (Directed by a Chinese national,Li Ying)which was partially made by the grant from Cultural Agency related organization,was canceled in four theaters in Tokyo and one in Osaka.This Japanese cinema blog run by Don Brown has summarized the ongoing incident.
http://www.ryuganji.net/2008/03/31/more-trouble-for-yasukuni-documentary-as-remaining-cinemas-pull-out/
Sonagi added these pithy words on 01 Apr 08 at 10:55 pmIt’s not only religious zealots who try to shut people up and try to control the message. Politicians and government officials use the same strategy.
Sonia added these pithy words on 02 Apr 08 at 4:00 pmFreedom of expression is a wonderful idea, but do we know where to draw the line?
Because of freedom of expression, we have hurt Muslims, Jews, and Christians alike. If anti-Koran film is freedom of expression; then if someone swears in public at that movie’s director is also expression!
Atleast, we could bring some logic in our arguments!
Joe added these pithy words on 04 Apr 08 at 12:45 pmSonia:
You are joking aren’t you?
The issue is not that someone swore at Geert Wilders – anyone and everyone can do that as much as they want.
The issue is that he was subjected to death threats and now must live under police protection, no TV station was willing the show due to intimidaton, live leak employees were threatened, the Netherlands had to implement a world wide plan to protect their citizens and embassies across the Islamic world etc. – this on the basis that Geert showed some quotations from the Qur’an and Hadith and some clips of Muslim salafists speaking.The line drawn with regard to Freedom of Expression has already been drawn – no infringement of Copyright or trademarks, no defamation, no incitement to violence, no “shouting fire in a crowded theatre” – together with the slightly more dubious no incitement to hatred.
SPEAK / ADD YOUR COMMENT
Comments are moderated.
