Entry details

Curzon
Author

Curzon

Date

January 2nd, 2008

Tags

,

Comments

3 Comments so far.
Add yours.

If Lawrence had split the Middle East

I just returned to Japan from a delightful Christmas trip to Australia. The Lady Curzon and myself divided our time between the economic center of Sydney and the capital of Canberra, where we spent several hours lost in the enormous War Memorial Museum, which is probably the most comprehensive war museum I have ever visited.

The museum had several special exhibits, including a special on Lawrence of Arabia and his role during World War I. Included in this exhibit was a map that Lawrence, a trained cartographer, drafted with regard to his proposal for the division of the Middle East.


Wikipedia has a larger graphic here.

Lawrence’s plan was very different from what the British colonial authorities designated. Under Lawrence’s plan:

  • + “Irak” was to be smaller, have King Abdullah in charge, include Kuwait, and be under direct British influence.
  • + West of that was to be an Arab state under more indirect British influence.
  • + The Armenians were to have their own state in the region of Cilicia, the Armenian state “given” to the Armenians by the Crusaders.
  • + Palestine was to follow its general historical borders.
  • + The French were to have an interest in what was to become Lebanon.
  • + Perhaps most importantly, most of Arabia was to be independent, ruled by Prince Faisel (with whom he fought with in Arabia), and free of any European influence.

We can only wonder what would have happened if his plans had been followed.

Comments to this entry

Chief Wiggum
January 2, 2008
5:38 pm
It's interesting how some states are devolving into smaller home-rule tribal entities (Scotland, Wales, Kosovo, maybe Flanders, Catalonia, Kurdistan, etc.), while at the same time tranzies are trying to make the EU a secular caliphate over all of Europe.
Curzon
January 3, 2008
2:44 am
The duality of tribalism v.s. globalism on that level has been a defining part of the post-Cold War world, from Scotland's new parliament in Europe to the Naxi in India and the ethnic groups of Indonesia.
Alfred Russel Wallace
January 3, 2008
3:22 am
The incompatibility of tribalism and democracy is being demonstrated again in Kenya...