Almost six years after the US toppled the Taliban in what appeared to be a bulldoze of poorly armed fanatics by a well-trained and hi-tech western professional military, the Taliban is making a real comeback. And Afghan President Hamid Karzai says that security had worsened over the past two years, and that the US is no closer to catching Bin Laden.
And those aren’t the only problems:
Mr Karzai is trying to rebuild his war-torn country and strengthen his fragile government while confronting a resurgent Taliban, a booming opium trade, government corruption, mounting deaths of civilians and an al-Qaeda leadership that, US intelligence officials say, has reconstituted itself in the mountainous border territory between Pakistan and Afghanistan.
The White House is trying to put on a positive face of the situation as Bush and Karzai meet in Camp David. Gordon Johndroe, National Security Council spokesman, said that Afghanistan presented both “progress and challenges… Afghanistan has come a long way since October 2001, when the US first went in, but there is clearly more work to do.” It’s disheartening to see that so little progress after so much has been sacrificed to aid this poor central asian nation.
- BROWSE / IN TIMELINE
- « Analyst Advice
- » Roundup
COMMENTS / 5 COMMENTS
Curzon added these pithy words on 06 Aug 07 at 5:19 pmThere have beem major efforts to be proud of: national highways, major transportation infrastructure, and a democratic government with potential to include all Afghans. Frankly, the economics of opium production in Afghanistan are bizarre and inexplicable, i.e. prices of heroin worldwide are going down yet prices for opium farmers in Afghanistan are going up. The bigger issue is that Karzai is mayor of Kabul. Outside, the warlords reign supreme, and now a resurgent Taliban are taking hold.
TDL added these pithy words on 07 Aug 07 at 4:36 pmMaybe a more targeted approach would have been more effective (but that is the past.) Instead of undermining the warlords, why not co-opt them? As I have not been following Afghanistan very closely I am not sure what the political environment is really like. My sense is that some warlords are being undermined, while others are being cultivated. Would it not be better to have all warlords brought into the national political system in some manner?
As for the opium. The fat margins will exist as long as the West demands that this commodity be illegal around the world. Once the silly “War on Drugs” in the West are done away with, margins will collapse for opium (as well as cocaine, marijuana, meth., etc.)
Regards,
TDL
feeblemind added these pithy words on 07 Aug 07 at 4:39 pmWretchard has a post at Belmont Club saying things are going fairly well. Taliban can’t recruit locals. Spring offensive failed. Challenge is for locals to be able to defend themsleves when the USA/UK leave. It is to Karzai’s advantsge to paint a bleak picture in order to get as much money from the USA as possible.
tequila added these pithy words on 07 Aug 07 at 6:37 pmWretchard says the same thing in different ways in pretty much every post. Follow his posts about Iraq pretty much throughout the entire war.
