Entry details

Curzon
Author

Curzon

Date

July 25th, 2007

Tags

,

Comments

5 Comments so far.
Add yours.

Perhaps there’s hope for China after all

24canal600.jpg

From the New York Times:

On an Ancient Canal, Grunge Gives Way to Grandeur

20070724_canal_map.jpgHANGZHOU, China — Until the early 1990s, crews on barges and boats chugging down China’s 2,400-year-old Grand Canal did not need familiar landmarks to tell them they were approaching the scenic city of Hangzhou.

They could smell it.

“The water was black,” said Zhu Jianbai, assistant director of the city government’s Grand Canal Restoration and Development Group. “There was no life in it. If you lived beside it, you had to live with the stink. It was an embarrassment.”

But a $250 million makeover that began in 2001 has improved water quality and spurred urban renewal along a 24-mile section of this ancient transport artery that once connected China’s great west-to-east river systems, carrying the goods, taxes and official communications that sustained successive dynasties.

Today, small fish swim among the pylons supporting cargo wharves where effluent from factories and raw sewage from homes had poisoned this section of the world’s oldest man-made waterway. Walkways and parkland line sections of the canal, and some of China’s most expensive apartment buildings have sprung up beside it on what has become prime real estate. Water taxis connect historic piers and bridges along the winding route through the city where old shop houses and tenements are being restored.

Most remarkably, the canal no longer smells.

On my two trips across China, covering more than half the country’s provinces, Mr. Zhu’s feelings are close to my own impressions of China. The country had a long and rich history and was potentially beautiful—yet the lack of any environmental conscious made it filthier than perhaps anywhere else on the planet. And in my experience, the environmental condition of China in 2003 was notable worse than other areas I had seen in the former USSR and parts of the Third World.

Yet I always had cause for hope when considering the case of Japan. My late grandfather remembers that in post-war Tokyo, people wore elevated shoes because sewage ran openly in the streets. Today, Tokyo is one of the cleanest capital cities in the world, and Japan as a country is generally very clean. Because countries don’t develop with clean environments—they reach a critical mass of wealth where the population demands certain minimum requirements for hygiene and clean air and water.

Perhaps China can follow Japan’s path, as environmental awareness increases. Hangzhou’s ultimate goal is to persuade the United Nations to list the canal as a UNESCO World Heritage site.

Comments to this entry

sun bin
July 25, 2007
5:29 am
20 years ago. it was even worse. the canal was totally black, like crude oil.
and it did stick.

there is a direct correlation between disposable income and environmental protection. for china, it has only just started.
it took japan some 20-30 years (perhaps longer for us/europe) to clean up as well. it should take at least similar length of time.
but i do not see china as clean as japan in 20 years, because in terms of wealth (eg measured by gdp/cap) there is still a very large gap even then.

but there will certainly be major improvement.
china » Blog Archive » Conference: China ”“ The Future of Travel
July 25, 2007
8:35 am
[...] HANGZHOU, China — Until the early 1990s, crews on barges and boats chugging down China's 2400-year-old Grand Canal did not need familiar landmarks to tell them they were approaching the scenic city of Hangzhou. They could smell it. … …more [...]
Kurt9
July 25, 2007
7:55 pm
They will do as Japan. Polution in Japan was so bad in the 1960's and early 70's that there were riots over it. People would baracade the doors of company HQ buildings so that the senior managers could not go home until they promised to do something about the polution. Although these protest tactics are unlikely in China, the government and large companies are feeling the heat from people about the polution.

Like the Japanese, the Chinese are a "consensus" people. They will largely agree that polution is a problem and will eventually deal with it. Taiwan was really bad in the 80's and 90's. It is gradually getting cleaner as well. China will follow suit.
Aceface
July 26, 2007
4:31 am
China may follow the footsteps of Japan and Taiwan only if they could develop quasi-democratic polity like the two in the next 20 years.
It takes more than just time and money to build a civic society,you know.
Gustav Vasa
July 26, 2007
11:08 am
Of course there is hope for China. A lot of countries (including Japan) are trying to help China clean up. That is the best lesson: Wealth means cooperation and increased interest in solutions that matter to people.

Your grandfather's story from Tokyo however is rather silly in the sense that it was Americans who firebombed the city (including its civilian quarters) and geta that you even link to are part of traditional Japanese dress code - so it has nothing to do with his "story" about sewage. Which part of Tokyo did he visit, I wonder. Are not a lot of Westerners telling the same kind of stories about China today...