
Gaza: one giant refuge camp surrounded by the farmlands of Israel and the barren desert of the Sinai.
This post began as an account of Hamas gains in Gaza, but it was out of date by the time I wrote it. In brief, the state of civil war in Gaza over the past month appears to be quickly concluding in an overwhelming victory for Hamas. The Islamists now appear to have taken over all Gaza, and Fatah forces have quickly lost ground under the onslaught by the better-armed and better-disciplined Islamist fighters.
A Hamas spokesman heralded a new “era of justice and Islamic rule.” Of course, Islamic rule so far has meant looting, tossing enemies alive off 15-story buildings, shot one another’s children, bursting into hospitals to finish off the wounded in their beds, the usual Taliban-esque “justice” that comes with the so-called law and order of theological tyranny.
The reaction in the Arab world?
- The Arab League called for a cease-fire, warning of “disaster” otherwise.
- Egypt called for all sides to cooperate (with Egyptian mediation) and threw Cairo’s support strongly behind Abbas.
- Jordan accused unnamed “regional forces” (i.e. Iran, which gives heavy financial support to Hamas). Half its population (2+ million) is Palestinian. A civil war in the West Bank as Gaza is experiencing now could easily spread into Jordan.
- Syria said Thursday it was following the events “with deep concern and pain” and called for Palestinian unity and “closing ranks to face the Israeli occupation.” A Hamas leader exiled in Syria insisted the fighting would not lead to a Gaza-West Bank split, saying the territories are “united and would remain so.” However, Fatah in the West Bank is already rounding up Hamas members to assert control, even as Fatah falls in Gaza.
- Saudi Arabia is silent, furious by the collapse of its high-profile mediation attempt in February in Mecca between Abbas and Hamas that created the unity government.
Outside the Middle East, the UN has called for a ceasefire, but I would be surprised if any nation volunteered peacekeepers to try and keep different factions of the Palestinians from killing each other. The Bush Administration requested that Israel open up Gaza’s sealed frontiers to allow shipments of weapons to Fatah. But PM Ehud Olmert refused on grounds that it was “too late.”
The new reality: a Gaza Strip controlled by the militant group Hamas and a West Bank held by the Fatah faction of President Mahmoud Abbas. The world is probably about to welcome the next (and smallest) Islamist [failed] state (or at least the first Islamist Enclave). Quite a qualifier for understanding the world’s newest state, but the truth nonetheless.
- BROWSE / IN TIMELINE
- « The Cost of Kosovo
- » Foreign oil and defence policy in Japan
COMMENTS / 12 COMMENTS
Hey, Free Lawyer Semen | Prose Before Hos added these pithy words on Jun 18 07 at 8:01 pm[...] since I wrote this piece on Palestine, I wanted to suggest a few others: The World’s Next (and Smallest) Islamist State, Why Martin Indyk Is Director Of The Saban Center for Middle East Policy And You’re Not, Is [...]
Dan tdaxp added these pithy words on 15 Jun 07 at 11:05 amIsrael must be quiet happy. She has been attempting to divide her neighbors for some time, and this is yet another step in that direction.
Jerusalem now borders a post-Naserite dictatorship (Egypt), a Hashemite monarchy (Jordan), a precarious Shia dictatorship (Syria), a Sunni-Catholic democracy (Lebanon), a Muslim Brotherhood quasi-State (Gaza), and a PLO state (West Bank).
Confusion to her enemies, indeed.
Chief Wiggum added these pithy words on 15 Jun 07 at 2:24 pmWhy does Israel continue to provide electricity and water to Gaza?
Will the victory of Hamas result in more aid or less aid to Gaza?
snow added these pithy words on 15 Jun 07 at 2:33 pmCertainly can’t see any two-state solution anytime soon with recent developments. I find it ironic that CNN and others in the MSM are ridiculing Bush over the failure of his pushing the two state solution. After all, most Democrats and many Republicans (and myself) were supportive of the idea. Instead of kicking Bush over the failure, they should be despairing that this supposedly cherished dream (that neither Hamas nor Fatah want-they want it all, no Israel at all) looks to be dead, if not buried for good.
ElamBend added these pithy words on 16 Jun 07 at 12:23 amHamas in full control will show Hamas by its full colors. It won’t be pretty, but it will force the world (especially Paelestinians) to acknowledge what they are. It is already forcing the Arab states that their biggest problems aren’t Israelis or Americans or even Palestinians (at least directly); it’s their Persian paymasters. If Hamas decides to directly confront Israel, any calls for restraint will surely be muted.
Israel may suffer as Fatah and Hamas try to show who hates the Jews the most (and is thus, most ‘legitimate’), but it’ll be pretty hard to fight Israel when they’re fighting each other.
alec added these pithy words on 16 Jun 07 at 2:43 amSo long and farewell to Fatah. Will anyone miss them? I certainly won’t.
Alfred Russel Wallace added these pithy words on 16 Jun 07 at 3:24 amI agree with Alec: ‘Arafat’s malignant spirit still casts a dark shadow over a group that has further mimiced his policies of graft and kleptocracy. ’ It would be almost funny if it wasn’t so tragic…
kende added these pithy words on 16 Jun 07 at 11:35 pmLet this be the end of the two-state mantra. A three state solution is long past due. Hamas can have it’s micro-state in Gaza. Fatah can negotiate with Israel for part (%60 give or take) of the West Bank in exchange for support against Hamas there and slow progress towards a quiet non-kleptocracy. If Gaza is recognized as it’s own state, any acts of war crossing it’s border with Israel can be treated clearly as such. No need for further occupation. They lob missiles into Israel, Israel can respond by cutting off water/electricity, placing a full embargo by sea, and invading just far enough in to impose a buffer zone on Gaza’s northern, eastern, and southern borders. World’s largest refugee camp indeed.
Now about Hezbollah, Syria, and Iran…
bingobangoboy added these pithy words on 17 Jun 07 at 11:03 amSo, after decades of negotiations & bloodshed, it’s to be revealed that all you need to do to be handed formal independence from Israel is to toss restraint & diplomacy out the window, and just be as tyranical as possible. I understand Gaza is barely worth fighting over (from Israel’s point of view), but is this really a step forward?
bingobangoboy added these pithy words on 17 Jun 07 at 11:05 amum, tyrannical.
Ignatius added these pithy words on 17 Jun 07 at 4:55 pmFinally the islamist can govern, so they can show to the world that they dont have the key for all the problems of the Middle East. As Islamic Revolution did in Iran.
They dont have the israeli occupacion or the “traitors” there. So they should bring the promised justice, progress and clean the criminality and the corruption.
Good luck.
snow added these pithy words on 18 Jun 07 at 4:40 amAgain, I find it odd that current events are being painted as ‘Bush’s failure’ yet again (as I read again in a CNN op-ed). Strange how this ‘failure’ is attributed to Bush alone, when the two state solution has been a favorite pet of many across the political spectrum (myself included).
What this event really shows, is that the supposedly more extreme supporters of Israel may in fact be right. You can’t deal with a terrorist organization that has a goal of Israel’s complete destruction and that a two-state solution was a fiction from the beginning. This is the story that the MSM is not promoting, instead using the event to yet again bash Bush for his ‘failure’.
SPEAK / ADD YOUR COMMENT
Comments are moderated.
