AUTOPOSTED! Am still on vacation
While I bask in the warm Caribbean sun, trek through the rainforests and indulge in other tropical delights, I thought it would behoove me to provide our readers with a short history of US involvement in the Caribbean and how Puerto Rico came to be part of the United States and how it was, in that sense, the luckiest of all its neighbors.
Adios España, hola Estados Unidos
As the Spanish empire was crumbling, only a few colonies remained scattered all over the globe, most descending into anarchy. A combination of yellow journalism regarding Spanish atrocities putting down various uprisings and the unexplained (and likely accidental) sinking of the USS Maine on February 15, 1898 ultimately led to an American declaration of war against Spain. With the homeland in turmoil and in real danger of civil war, the Spanish were in no position to back down and instead chose to fight a war they knew they couldn’t win.
American, still relatively aloof in the world, acted quickly defeating the Spanish fleet off Manila in the Philippines and swiftly invading Cuba, site of the give cause for war. Not long after, the U.S. landed in Guánica, Puerto Rico and easily took the island with little resistance put up. When the war ended with a humiliating Spanish defeat, America had gained the Philippines, Guam, Puerto Rico and Cuba, although Cuba was granted independence as the ubiquity of American economic involvement there made actual ownership of the island unnecessary on top of being unwanted.
Under American Rule
Puerto Rico began under military rule and by 1917, all Puerto Ricans were granted American citizenship, which they still enjoy today. Puerto Rico went on to be granted the right to democratically elect its own government yet still remain a territorial part of the United States. As time went on, large scale migration from Puerto Rico began specifically to New York City and Boston. By the 1950s, efforts were underway to help Puerto Rico, or “the island” as it’s called there, move from an agricultural to industrial economy.

Puerto Rico has benefited considerably from its status as part of the United States. Its inhabitants hold American citizenship, trade and travel between the 50 states and Puerto Rico is as easy as crossing any other state line, and most importantly for tourists, there’s no limit to how much Bacardi you can take back to the mainland after visiting the factory in San Juan. But joking aside, despite the island’s problems such as high unemployment (12%), crime and poverty, they are still far above the rest of their neighbors who weren’t lucky enough to remain under US rule.
As the CIA factbook notes:
Puerto Rico has one of the most dynamic economies in the Caribbean region. A diverse industrial sector has far surpassed agriculture as the primary locus of economic activity and income. Encouraged by duty-free access to the US and by tax incentives, US firms have invested heavily in Puerto Rico since the 1950s. US minimum wage laws apply.
In addition, Puerto Rico gets about 5 million tourists a year.
What the heck is Puerto Rico?
Puerto Rico is officially defined as an unincorporated territory of the United States classified as a Commonwealth. It enjoys a significant amount of autonomy but also many of the benefits of normal American states. Puerto Ricans are American citizens yet can’t vote for the president, only their own. At the same time, they can live and work in the US as freely as any other American and serve in the military. They do not pay federal income tax but do pay U.S. federal payroll taxes as well as receive Social Security and some Medicaid.
Far from being the victim of evil American imperialism as some would have, Puerto Rico not only enjoys broad autonomy, but also has the right to choose its status and has repeatedly opted to remain part of America. Votes in 1967, 1993 and 1998 all reached the same conclusion. While some favor independence, a large portion (around 45%) of the island wishes to become a state yet has always narrowly lost referendums to do so.
My next post will briefly look at Puerto Rico’s neighbors and why they turned out to be the luckiest in the neighborhood insofar as becoming part of the United States and why American reluctance to follow through elsewhere led to the chain of failed state islands we have today, not so unlike in Oceania.
- BROWSE / IN TIMELINE
- « Ethiopia wins!
- » Saddam executed?!
COMMENTS / 10 COMMENTS
J.Kende added these pithy words on 29 Dec 06 at 2:19 pmIf it weren’t for the luck of P.R. remaining part of the U.S., I wouldn’t exist today. I wish more of the Caribbean could have been as lucky.
Sonagi added these pithy words on 29 Dec 06 at 2:22 pmPuerto Rican immigrants to the United States are diversifying their destinations. We count several families among our ESL students in our Shenandoah Valley community. The kids seem to have a stronger academic background than their peers from Mexico and Central America.
Raul added these pithy words on 30 Dec 06 at 12:44 amSaludos desde Puerto Rico,
Although Puerto Ricans have benefited from the US colonial relationship, the US and its companies have been the ones to benefit the most.
Until 1952 it was illegal to fly the Puerto Rican flag in Puerto Rico. One of the longest FBI COINTELPRO programs of repression still funtions in Puerto Rico. Pro Independence advocates have been are still harrassed and followed by the US FBI.
It took 50 years for the US to “allow” Puerto Ricans to elect their own governor.
In a world where colonialism is a thing of the last century, Puerto Rico, Guam and Virgin Islands still hold the title of colonies of the US.
Kenneth added these pithy words on 30 Dec 06 at 5:50 pmWhoohoo! Vacation! I’m in the Carribean too, but unfortunately I’ve been rather seasick of late….
Luis added these pithy words on 01 Jan 07 at 7:25 pmHola!
“The 51st State that Wasn’t and Still Isn’t”
I find “The 51st State that Wasn’t and Still Isn’t” to be, though too short, an unbiased and well researched look at the history of Puerto Rico.
The facts are there, just look at any of the other now independent countries that used to be US territories and Puerto Rico’s neighbors, they still depend heavily on agriculture, all their financial/economic fundamentals are lagging that of PR, they lack a broad middle class, and so on…. Yes, we do suffer from high unemployment and criminality, but that’s to be blamed on our lazy and corrupt politicians.
Puerto Rico will evidently do even better as the 51st State of the Union.
Happy New Year!
Luis
Sonagi added these pithy words on 01 Jan 07 at 11:12 pm
Sonagi added these pithy words on 01 Jan 07 at 11:12 pmOops, I meant to post that link on one of the Saddam threads.
Raul added these pithy words on 02 Jan 07 at 1:59 amThroughout the Caribbean economic growth rates are higher than those of Puerto Rico. The old advantages of being a US colony in terms of the tariffs on articles etc are no longer. Yet we are still stuck with the disadvantages of having to ship our products in US boats.
It is time for Puerto Ricans on these islands to view ourselves as what we are part of the Caribbean, part of Latin America and not part of New York City.
lirelou added these pithy words on 03 Jan 07 at 1:37 amThis is a repeat which apparently failed to appear. Raul is incorrect in his alleged fact that it was illegal to fly the Puertorrican flag in Puerto Rico until 1952. I would suggest that he read Luis Ferrao’s excellent “Pedro Albizu Campos y el nacionalismo puertorriqueno”. What was illegal was to use the Puertorrican flag as a symbol of a political party. The party in question that did so was the Nationalist Party. Indeed, when the Puertorrican flag was adopted by the legislature (sosmetime in the 1930s), that party staged a riot in protest to its being flown over public buildings.
Actually, Congress has the power to unilaterally grant Puerto Rico independence. Thay should do so, and save much of the $22 billion a year spent on welfare and matching funds that essentially keep the island looking far more prosperous than it is. Puerto Rico has long lost any strategic value it had for defence purposes, and is presently a drain on the national economy. To grant it independence would not deprive anyone of their U.S. citizenship. Those who wish to retain it will do so. Presumably, they can consider to reside in Puerto Rico just as a million or so U.S. and Canadians reside in Mexico. as foreigners. Thus those who truly believe in Puerto Rico as an independent nation-state, can set about proving that they have what it takes to run it. Or, in the alternative, prove to the world that they cannot, and suffer the verdict of history.
lirelou added these pithy words on 03 Jan 07 at 5:01 amSmall correction to the above. The 16 April 1932 riot by the Nationalist Party in the Capitol Bldg, in protest to an act in the P.R. senate which would have made the Puertorrican flag the sole emblem of the Insular government (i.e., the colonial government) may have succeeded in killing the bill. In any event, the legislature did not prohibit the flying of the Puertorrican flag. Rather they prohibited its use as the symbol of a political party. (Apparently too late to stop the printing up of ballots for elections that year which, if memory of “Historia de los partidos politicos puertorriquenos” is correct, displayed the (current) Puertorrican flag as the Nationalist Party emblem. See Luis Angel Ferrao, Albizu op. cit., p. 80.
