Entry details

Chirol
Author

Chirol

Date

September 15th, 2006

Tags

,

Comments

4 Comments so far.
Add yours.

Micronightmares

I’ve written about microstates in the past, noting both the good and the bad. Here’s more of the bad:

Moldova: Breakaway Transdniester To Hold Referendum Amid International Isolation

PRAGUE, September 14, 2005 (RFE/RL)—Moldova’s separatist Transdniester region is due to hold a referendum over the weekend to decide whether it should stay independent in order to join the Russian Federation in the future, or give up independence and reunite with Moldova. The Moldovan authorities have strongly condemned the vote. While the international community has largely shunned the poll, Moscow has not said whether it will recognize the results of the referendum.

Following and perhaps tarnishing the good example set by Montenegro, as predicted, Moldova is trying to run a play from the same book. The questions on the upcoming referendum are

“Do you support the course toward the Dniester Republic’s independence and ensuing future free accession to the Russian Federation?” And “Do you consider it possible that the Dniester Republic give up its independence and then join Moldova?

Making matters worse is the November referendum in Georgia’s breakaway region of South Ossetia (which Chirol plans to visit next year). In response to the Transdniester question, Russia issued a vague response that referendums are “seen in recognized democratic states as an important legal basis for building civil society.” True, and it seems Moscow is hoping that if given enough rope, democracies will hang themselves by recognizing Kosovo and Montenegro but not South Ossetia, Abkhazia, Transdniester, Karbagh etc. clearly hoping to discredit the West and gain ground in its former near abroad. Despite the obvious hypocrisy with regard to Russia’s war against Chechnya, Putin is surely banking on the terrorist issue keeping Western governments from pointing that out.

Montenegro may have set a good example, but that won’t stop others from misusing it. Incidentally, I’d like to note that this case has more to do unfinished structural changes in the former USSR than an international trend such as elsewhere like Great Britain and Spain.

Comments to this entry

Dan tdaxp
September 15, 2006
2:28 am
Don't forget the Serb Republic of Bosnia!
Pacific Empire » Blog Archive » Should Auckland declare independence?
September 15, 2006
4:09 pm
[...] Recent examples of this trend have included the two newest sovereign states, East Timor and Montenegro. Montenegro’s successful referendum on independence sparked debate on blogs including Coming Anarchy and John Robb’s Global Guerrillas. More recently, John Robb mentioned that he is thinking of writing a book about successful seccessions. Coming Anarchy’s Chirol, linking to several earlier posts about the trend to fragmentation and microstates, posted about Transdniester - Moldova’s breakaway republic, born of civil war and controlled by organised crime, the bad side of fragmentation. Interestingly, Montenegro’s secession is peaceful partly because the EU provides an overarching structure which can resolve disputes in Europe, and both Montenegro and Serbia want to join the EU. On the other hand, the involvement of Russia - itself a multinational federation including several small autonomous republics - is a threat to peace, according to Chirol, when it comes to fragmentation in Moldova and the South Caucasus. [...]
ComingAnarchy.com » Blog Archive » Vote to Nowhere
September 18, 2006
8:47 am
[...] The results are in of Transdniester’s important yet meaningless vote: [...]
ComingAnarchy.com » Blog Archive »
September 18, 2006
12:46 pm
[...] [...]