Both Curzon and I are very skeptical if not downright cynical towards the latest events in Nepal. Despite the King’s abdication and a shakey ceasefire, things aren’t as they seem. The following BBC article takes note of several developments yet fails to see the big picture.
Maoists strive to win hearts and mindsFour months into the ceasefire in Nepal, Maoist rebels and the army are preparing to be confined in camps under United Nations monitoring. The Maoists are refusing to disarm completely. Indeed, there are fresh reports of them abducting and even killing people in some places. But in other locations they are on a drive to win ordinary people’s hearts and minds. They have also started building camps in their own favoured locations.
Building camps? Surely innocuous business.
“The current ceasefire requires a place for us to be together,” says Comrade Seetal, the brigade’s commissar or senior political figure.[...] the UN monitoring plan will confine the rebels and their big weapons to camps, it does not embrace the smaller weapons held by the Maoist militia (equivalent to their police) or other militias.
In the village camp, the Maoists are filling their leisure time. There are regular literacy classes for their own less educated troops. In the evening light after the rain, a volleyball match.
Given that the Maoists already control a good portion of the country, the current ceasfire gives them de facto rule over it and an opportunity to consolidate control, reorganize and regroup not to mention train soldiers. The situation sounds eerily familiar to Lebanon. In keeping with Mao’s stages of guerilla war, the Maoists are now turning themselves into a conventional army to make the final push into the capital. Like the many so-called ceasefires and agreements during Vietnam, this one is nothing more than a ploy.
- BROWSE / IN TIMELINE
- « Hoder on WaPo: Iran needs nukes
- » Islam and Victorianism
COMMENTS / 11 COMMENTS
ElamBend added these pithy words on 26 Aug 06 at 6:25 pmLetting the Maoist build garrisons without harrassment is peace? Sounds like consolidation of power to me.
Lexington Green added these pithy words on 26 Aug 06 at 10:25 pmMao would be proud.
Dan tdaxp added these pithy words on 26 Aug 06 at 11:15 pmSickeningly, I’ve run across intelligent people who are happy with this, and know where it leads.
sun bin added these pithy words on 27 Aug 06 at 12:08 am1) i suppose you guys know that what happened in the past year was not a revolution, or a solution to all the problems. so don’t view it that way.
however, what has happened was a significant improvement over absolute monarchy dictatorship or total anarchy. therefore it is good development, and hence the optimism.2) i also wonder how many people in the west really understand what Mao’s guerilla warfare is. it seems what i have read is very different from what Mao implemented, therefore the surprise you mentioned. mingling with people, providing basic govt infrastructure, was always part of the guerilla playbook.
if you did not see it in your previously reading, that was because these people (e.g. Dalai’s team in 1960) were not true guerilla (and hence doomed to fail).
ElamBend added these pithy words on 27 Aug 06 at 2:18 amBut of course, the guerilla attacks the policeman and the teacher because they are symbols of the power of the state. If they succeed in driving them away, the guerilla then has the monopoly on power, which it must use to tax and then provide services.
snow added these pithy words on 27 Aug 06 at 4:38 pmAnarchy is certainly not a good situation, but who pushed the country into anarchy? The Maoists had a direct hand in this. I just can’t believe, considering the history of communist governments in the region, that any of this will come out for the better for the Nepalese people, and in fact, I expect it will be much much worse than the best case scenarios other leftists such as the BBC feel will happen. What will the BBC say if the Maoists start looking and acting a bit like the Khmer Rouge?
sun bin added these pithy words on 28 Aug 06 at 7:04 amno, maoist guerilla is not the source of the problem. it is just a bad solution to the problem.
source of the problem is the incompetent and corrupted king.
jon added these pithy words on 28 Aug 06 at 2:47 pmThe maoists are probably the second worst solution possibl to this situation. The only one that could be worse is complete anarchy.
Keeping an incompetent and corrupt king would probably be better for the people in the long wrong, as long as he wasn’t a despotic killer.
Elizabeth added these pithy words on 29 Aug 06 at 4:09 amAppreciate very much the continued focus on Nepal here, especially the comments by those who follow even more closely. I suppose I agree with most of the commenters… it’s hard to imagine which is worse, disorganized violence or organized violence.
Dr. Alfred Russel Wallace added these pithy words on 29 Aug 06 at 10:29 amThe Economist reports (Aug 26) that the American ambassador compared the country to Russia between February and October 1917…
Elizabeth added these pithy words on 29 Aug 06 at 5:51 pmDr- So who is Trotsky, then, and how can we find him?
