I’ve been meaning to write about some hotspots that have shown up in the news this week. In lieu of posts on each borderline civil war, here’s a summary of the chaos now taking over East Timor, Afghanistan, and Somalia.

EAST TIMOR: The Government v.s. Rebel Army Units, allied Police Forces, and Gangs
The West has almost a romantic infatuation with East Timor since its fight for independence from Indonesia. The current rebellion that has divided the country has shown that the country isn’t the paradise many thought it was.
East Timor may be small, but it has tribal divides. Last month, 500 troops rebelled after they were dismissed for protesting over what they said was discrimination against soldiers from the east of the country. (Most of the military leadership comes from the west). A handful of soldiers wouldn’t seem a big deal, but they were joined by machete-weilding gangs and even some regional police bureaus, and the simmering tensions have now turned into a bloody rebellion. Scores have been killed, official residences torched by rioters, and more revenge retaliations seem inevitable. The government is in no position to reassert authority, as the army and police force both have divided loyalties. The authority on the streets are Malaysian and Australian “peacekeeping” troops. The rebels have now fled to the countryside, where most of the population live, and there is no quick fix to this problem. (Australia has said it will not meddle with East Timor’s domestic politics.)
AFGHANISTAN: Karzai and the US v.s. Taliban Remnants
It’s easy to forget, but there are still Taliban in Afghanistan and they are still a threat to the government. These leftovers have recently been stepping up ambushes, and US strikes in retaliation have killed civilians, straining US-Afghan relations. President Karzai has called for an investigation into one recent air strike that left several families dead, while the US military has said militants fired on coalition forces from inside villagers homes and returned fired in self defence. Meanwhile, thousands have fled to avoid the fighting.
SOMALIA: “No idea who is fighting who”
On the geopolitical surface, the current fighting in Somalia looks great for Western interests: Mogadishu’s infamous warlords are fighting the latest threat to their power, none other than Bin Laden-inspired Islamists trying to turn the country into the next Saudi Arabia. Forget Black Hawk Down —the US is actually covertly helping the warlords:
The warlords have ruled Mogadishu for 15 chaotic years, using young gunmen to extract as much revenue as they can from checkpoints, ports and airstrips within their turf. They have struck alliances with business leaders, who pay protection money to enable them to trade with Gulf states.But Islamic leaders have quietly emerged as a third force, one with huge political, economic and military clout. They have slowly filled a void in anarchic Somalia, creating Islamic schools and courts and providing social services unavailable anywhere else.
Amid the moderate sheiks, however, are hard-liners whom American officials say have formed a small Al Qaeda cell in Mogadishu. To combat the extremists, American intelligence officials struck an alliance with the warlords, who fashioned themselves into a counterterrorism alliance.
On the ground, the situation is truly awful, with major civilian casualties in what can best be described as a feudal society with no modern medicine—wheelbarrows are used as “ambulances.” Street fights between rival militias are resulting in massive civilian casualties, and there is no way for any international help to reach the people.
On a somewhat positive note, Sri Lanka, Nepal and the Solomon Islands all look better than they did last month. We can only hope it’s a trend.

Comments to this entry
germanicus
May 27, 2006
6:22 am
Zorobabel
May 27, 2006
7:01 am
It's really too bad. East Timor is the poorest country in the world in purchasing power terms, and this was set to be the first year of real economic expansion (some were estimating 5%). Now that has obviously been reversed, but I believe this is the only the beginning of what will become chronic strife for East Timor.
Elizabeth
May 27, 2006
10:22 am
But I agree: this is not only the Taliban. The United States is not only fighting the Taliban, but all the tribes of the south which have never yet submitted to "foreign" rule of their own lands, or Kabul (foreign including that of Tajiks, Uzbeks, or others). The Taliban has become an umbrella party for a variety of tribal groups, though- this is why it is "blamed".
If the Taliban were to disappear as a party, though, the war would go on.
germanicus
May 27, 2006
3:29 pm
He also said, and apparently I didn't make clear, that increases of violent attacks seem to be part of the rite of spring in Afghanistan--my words not his, but similar message.
Kirk H. Sowell
May 27, 2006
10:05 pm
South Africa: A nationwide strike threatens to throw the country with the world's highest murder rate into "anarchy" - and that is President Mbeki's word. Last I read the murder rate in SA was around eight times that of Russia, which in turn is far higher than that of any Western country, but now the security guards union has gone on strike over lack of pay and bad treatment. Worse, they have started attacking anyone who attempts to work as a security guard during the strike. Between AIDS and the crime issue, this is a country which could literally come apart.
This is from Radio France Internationale: Afrique de Sud: La Colere des guardes degeneres en violence.
Afghanistan: It might be better to say that the Taliban are engaging in a counteroffensive from their bases in Pakistan, rather than suggesting that they are "leftovers," although some of them are that. But really what we have seen is the Talibanization of the borderlands of western Pakistan, where the tribes are loyal to the Taliban and supportive of Bin Laden. This has been going on for a while, but it has stepped up recently. The Pakistani military has of course been engaging in operations in these areas, but they have been only partially successful. The Taliban is stronger in Pakistan than in Afghanistan.
And the drug trade does play a big part in it, ironically. The opium/heroin trade apparently accounts for about half of Afghanistan's economy. Afghan drug traders have been moving up the supply chain and setting up heroin production in country, thus increasing their profits. The Taliban have thus been able to opportunistically take advantage of resentment of eradication efforts by the NATO-backed government in Kabul.
Somalia: Clinton was right to get us involved in Somalia back in the 1990s but his mistake was to (1) fail to perceive this as a security front and thus put it forward like a humanitarian cause, and (2) cut and run when there American casualties. We should have stayed, assuming the administration was willing to put the forces on the ground necessary to make sure we could win a firefight.
Now, things are so bad it is hard to see what could be done, but we have to try. If there were actually any Muslim countries willing to expend the blood and treasure necessary to force some order on the country, they would be the ideal intervention force. But there isn't of course. A Western intervention force would have to be large enough to lock down the entire country and willing to kill a whole lot of teenagers with machine guns, and needless to say there isn't the will for that in the U.S. or other Western societies.
Elizabeth
May 28, 2006
7:21 am
You would imagine wrong, because in fact, the deaths in 2006 (not only of coalition troops but of civilians etc.) have exceeded the deaths in the past three years together. Look it up.
And read what I wrote carefully: "there has been an increase in deaths from violent attacks in Afghanistan over past springs, as well."
I got it. Every year, the army says, "Hey, guys, it's getting worse." And the government says, "Ah, spring!" And the army says, "Yeah, spring, but worse than last spring..." and the government says, "Ah, spring!"
It's worse than the winter, and it's worse than last spring, and last spring was really bad. Last spring was worse than the spring before that. And the spring before that was worse than the spring before that.
Elizabeth
May 28, 2006
7:31 am
Heh. Such efforts really make me smile. When Dostum's got his guys in parliament, the last Minister of the Interior resigned saying that the drug issue "permeates the very top" of Afghanistan's government... when we know that all of our northern alliance guys have got a poppy in every pocket- do you really think we are working hard at that?
And the reason the Taliban take advantage of resentment is that they are the ones that have sold the poppy seeds, on credit, to the farmers... they will get their loans back in kind with raw opium, and sell it. If the crop is destroyed, they just tell the farmer, TOO BAD, you still have to pay back the loan, and take his cow or daughter or whatever.
Now, that's not the "real" Taliban. THat's the Pashtun tribesmen who commit many of the crimes and do much of the fighting against invaders, including Engllish, Russians, Americans, whomever comes their way. These guys are fighting under the Taliban now, but even if Pakistan shut down shop and got out, you'd still be fighting them to the very last man. In the end it could be 600 American tanks against one Pashtun 10-year-old boy but he won't cry, and he will take out as many people as he can before he goes... that is the enemy, not some bogeyman Taliban.
Eddie
May 28, 2006
1:36 pm
This would be an utter disaster for S. Africa, Africa in general and the US and its allies. S. Africa needs a competent technocrat as its next leader, not a demagogue.
Regarding E. Timor, I think too often we overlook the terrible, debilitating impact a quarter century (or more in other cases) of ruthless oppression has on a society. Nearly 1/4 of E. Timor's population was wiped out between '75 and '99, can we really expect them to be building a competent government so soon with free market economic policies and laws that we ourselves don't have in our own country (or Australia for that matter).
Jay
May 29, 2006
4:30 am
"Ronin":http://fallbackbelmont.blogspot.com/2006/05/ronin.html
Zorobabel
May 29, 2006
6:45 pm
Curzon
May 29, 2006
11:17 pm
Elizabeth
May 30, 2006
4:59 am
And of course, this is all besides the airstrikes outside of Kandahar.
ComingAnarchy.com » Blog Archive » Islamic Control of Somalia Spreading
June 15, 2006
7:22 pm