Entry details

Curzon
Author

Curzon

Date

May 16th, 2006

Tags

,

Comments

11 Comments so far.
Add yours.

City of God


“We’re at war with them, there will be more casualties, but we won’t back down.’’ State Military police Chief Colonel Elizeu Teixeira Borges

The current chaos in Sao Paulo was sparked five days ago, when authorities transfered eight leaders of the First Capital Command gang (“PCC”) to a high-security facility near Rio de Janeiro. The PCC retaliated by attacking police cars and stations with bullets and bombs, sparking chaos that overflowed into the prison. Attacks have now spread to banks and buses, and the deathtoll has now reached 90 with many guards in the prison still hostage. In a whopping serves-you-right for bleeding heart liberalism, the violence intensified after thousands of prisoners were freed for the weekend to visit Mom on Mother’s Day.

The PCC is more than a mafia—it’s a criminal trade union. Members contribute monthly dues to a central fund that bribes police officers, hires lawyers, and provides for members’ families while they are in prison. When violence such as this does erupt, it is coordinated and widespread. As a Katrina-esque example of the perils of federalism, President Lula offered to send 4,000 elite troops to help, which were refused by Sao Paulo Gov. Claudio Lembo who insisted the help wasn’t needed. And there will be more casualties before this is over.

FOOTER: The post title is a reference to this.

Comments to this entry

Gollios
May 16, 2006
1:53 pm
Curzon, I was wondering when that movie would come up on CA. I was fortunate enough to be introduced to it by some Brazillian friends who provided a lot of good background & commentary as I watched. Also on the DVD is a documentary about the rise of the PCC.
Curzon
May 16, 2006
2:16 pm
The documentary you mention is even better than the film itself -- a truly scary look into how criminal organizations can rule a society.
alec
May 16, 2006
3:28 pm
"I'm a playboy now."

On a serious note, South American gangs tend to be a lot less like the American sense of 'gangs', and more like small privately funded armies.
snow
May 16, 2006
4:18 pm
Yikes, it sounds like a seriously bad scene down there. I once met a guy at a travel agency in India who railed on for 20 minutes about how disgusting, dirty, disorganized, crime-ridden and uncivilized India was (I didn't have the heart to tell him that I was in no hurry and that I loved the place-most of the time). I asked him where he was from and he said Brazil.
Prose Before Hos » News to Spit on Your Antiquated Views
May 16, 2006
6:01 pm
[...] Coming Anarchy has a good post on the recent violence that has swept through San Paolo, Brazil, mainly from one of the world’s largest and best managed criminal organizations. Plus it references one of the best movies made in the past 25 years, City of God. [...]
marquer
May 16, 2006
8:58 pm

...a truly scary look into how criminal organizations can rule a society.

As a Yank, I am fully conversant with how criminal organizations can rule a society. Here, though, we employ the genteel circumlocution of referring to them as "political parties".
Tiu Fu Fong
May 18, 2006
4:34 am
If you liked the movie, see City of Men (http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0364801/). The story in the TV series is independent of the movie story, features some of the same actors and is generally excellent.
ComingAnarchy.com » Blog Archive » Forget the Gap, try the Middle Ages
May 19, 2006
12:53 pm
[...] While failed states have been a hot topic since we learned the hard way that we ignore those states, like Afghanistan, at our own peril, the idea is more nuanced than we believe. If we take the recent violence in Brazil for example, we see state failure, but we also see alternative suppliers of sovereignty. Walking into any Brazilian favela, assuming you aren’t killed, is like entering a mini-state where local gangs provide security, basic services, a form of government and even detain “criminals.” Sounds more like a fuedal state than a failed one. Yet, Brazil is certainly not alone. As I saw firsthand, everything south of central Beirut is Hizballah country where they provide not only security, basic services and a political outlet for their citizens, but also education, television programming and more. The same goes for Hamas in Palestine. [...]
phil jones
May 22, 2006
4:46 pm
What you should also see is "Carandiru", the film about the massacre of over 100 prisoners in the early 90s. ( http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0293007/" )

I think the PCC were formed in response to this massacre. They started as a kind of prisoner's defence organization. And have always been at war with the police.
ComingAnarchy.com » Blog Archive » Connectivity and Chaos in Brazil
May 24, 2006
1:21 pm
[...] In a followup to my earlier post on the prison riots taking place in Brazil, it turns out that the attacks have been coordinated by cell phones held by prisoners. [...]
ComingAnarchy.com » Blog Archive » City of God II
March 3, 2007
1:12 am
[...] Gang rule of prisons isn’t limited to Brazil—it’s an epidemic across Latin America [...]