Entry details

Curzon
Author

Curzon

Date

December 6th, 2005

Tags

Comments

14 Comments so far.
Add yours.

Geomapping Problems, Part 1: NASA World Wind

You all know I’m a geography-cartography nut. Perhaps I’m being sensitive, but fellow geography enthusiasts will probably share my frustration with NASA World Wind’s muddled political borders. The program’s only been around for ten months, how can it show borders that haven’t existed in years, even decades?

Iraqi-Saudi Neutral Zone still exists (partitioned in 1969):

Yemen is still divided into two countries (unified sometime in the late 1990s; date sketchy):

Belarus is part of Russia (independent since 1990):

There are plenty of other problems similar to this—Eritrea doesn’t exist, the Holy See has no borders, Hong Kong SAR still has borders. Does this mean I’m switching to Google Earth? No—they’ve got their own problems, which I’ll get to in the next post.

Comments to this entry

Dan tdaxp
December 6, 2005
1:46 am
The Iraqi-Saudi Arabia zone was paritioned in 1969? I remember seeing it on every map during the Persian Gulf War.
RichL
December 6, 2005
2:26 am
The problem presents a clear argument for NASA to become part of the State Dept.!
Walter
December 6, 2005
2:56 am
North Yemen and South Yemen were united about 1990 according to a "Sponsored Section" by Yemen in Foreigh Affairs.
Daniel Nexon
December 6, 2005
3:49 am
President Lukashenko clearly has an operative in NASA.
davesgonechina
December 6, 2005
5:26 am
one thing I've been looking for is world wind plugin that will "flatten" a map. Open sourcing it for plugins, though, will mean faster corrections. NASA has laid out a helluva framework to get these things done.
Curzon
December 6, 2005
5:29 am
Dan: you can't fool me, you were in your diapers during Persian Gulf one! But "see here.":http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iraq-saudi_arabia_neutral_zone

Walter: formally yes, but it took a few years to actually happen.
Curzon
December 6, 2005
5:32 am
DGC: view -> vertical exageration -> 0.0x !!
davesgonechina
December 6, 2005
6:54 am
sweet.
sun bin
December 6, 2005
7:25 am
formally registered in 1991.
i also remember that famous parallelogram.

the wiki link said the saudi-kuwait NZ was partitioned in 1969.
Dan
December 6, 2005
7:37 am
Dan: you can't fool me, you were in your diapers during Persian Gulf one! But see here.


I thought you said I was a middle-aged, truck-driver going on his third divorse...

Keep your slurs consistent! Don't be a Kerry! :-)
Dan
December 6, 2005
7:39 am
PS: LOL

For unknown reasons the treaty was not filed with the United Nations and nobody outside Iraq and Saudi Arabia was officially notified or shown the text giving the new map coordinates
ComingAnarchy.com » Blog Archive » Geomapping Problems, Part 2: Google Earth
December 6, 2005
2:56 pm
[...] Geomapping Problems, Part 1: NASA World WindGoogle Earth, step aside!Gotta Love Google EarthFrontlineGoogling efficiently [...]
tdaxp
May 3, 2006
4:28 pm
Catholicgauze Riseth

Catholicgauze, the writer who got his blogosphere start here at tdaxp with his three-part reporting on H.J. de Blij (on the topics of China, climate change, and Islamic terrorism) has been making his influence felt on the blogosphere. Today he is link...
Catholicgauze
May 3, 2006
5:42 pm
Blast you Coming Anarchy! You have beaten me again!