Entry details

Younghusband
Author

Younghusband

Date

November 24th, 2005

Tags

Comments

9 Comments so far.
Add yours.

Baer naked

The new film Syriana (see a preview here) is sure to stoke the fires of political polarity this December. The main character, Bob Barnes, is supposedly loosely based on Robert Baer, author of See No Evil: The True Story of a Ground Soldier in the CIA’s War on Terrorism and Sleeping With the Devil: How Washington Sold Our Soul for Saudi Crude. Mr Baer now writes for The Atlantic Monthly along with our Mr Kaplan, and is credited as a writer for Syriana. He has appeared in another movie Uncovered: The War on Iraq which I haven’t seen and cannot comment on. (Anybody else that can, please speak up).

To get to the point, I am concerned at the mixing of Mr Baer (who I admire for his career and first book) with the likes of George Clooney (who I admire as an actor) and Matt Damon (MATT DAMON!). Reading Slate’s take on Syriana it looks my “realist” sensitivities are to be insulted:

Champions of the current administration like to label people who question its rhetoric””?who simply raise the possibility that acts of terrorism emanating from the Middle East have as much to do with the U.S.’s historical role in the region as with terrorists’ “pure evil” and “hatred of our freedoms”“”?as “fifth columnists,” “traitors,” “hate America firsters,” “Chomskyites,” “Michael Moore-ish conspiracy nuts,” etc. Given that climate … it’s a bloody miracle to see a movie like Syriana (Warner Bros.) emerge from a major studio. … The more we learn about How Things Work in the global economy, the more we despair that the rock will ever be lifted and the maggots exposed to sunlight.

This rubs up on one of my main sources of reverse-culture shock when talking to people at home who think that the rest of the world looks just like our nice, safe little post-modern suburbia. Doesn’t anybody read Hobbes anymore? Anyway, I am not sure how moralistic and/or judgemental Syriana will be, but I am sure the War Studies crew will be down there to check it out and rip it apart. Anybody else going?

Comments to this entry

Dan tdaxp
November 25, 2005
12:51 am
Liberal + money = bitching
Curzon
November 25, 2005
3:36 am
Great link Dan.

At 14, he concluded the world's problems were getting so bad that he, personally, had to do something about it. Thus was his course set for life. ``For me, the end goal was always to be doing something to change the world,'' Skoll says. And now he's trying to do it, one movie at a time.


* sigh *
Joe
November 25, 2005
3:16 pm
On the other hand, us bloggers don't need money to bitch.
Dan tdaxp
November 25, 2005
5:11 pm
Nah, when bloggers attack, it's a bitch-slap.
snow
November 25, 2005
6:02 pm
Hello, fellow posters and readers. Thought I would let you know about a very interesting article written by Nixon's Secretary of Defense during the Vietnam War comparing that one to the Iraq War. Great stuff!
http://www.foreignaffairs.org/20051101faessay84604/melvin-r-laird/iraq-learning-the-lessons-of-vietnam.html

(Sorry, didn't know where else to post this).
snow
November 25, 2005
6:05 pm
Hmm, the link doesn't seem to work, but if you go to the foreign affairs website, it is the lead article. Cheers! I hope it's as interesting for others as it was for me.
Curzon
November 25, 2005
6:45 pm
"Here is the link":http://www.foreignaffairs.org/20051101faessay84604/melvin-r-laird/iraq-learning-the-lessons-of-vietnam.html
IJ
November 25, 2005
8:00 pm
Speaking of Hobbes, some people think his ideas should be the policy for distributing the world's remaining oil reserves. A fictional take is "here":http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talk:Red_Storm_Rising#NATO.
IJ
December 8, 2005
10:46 am
More about "Syriana":http://www.theoildrum.com/story/2005/12/7/10825/4113.