Entry details

Younghusband
Author

Younghusband

Date

October 6th, 2005

Tags

,

Comments

5 Comments so far.
Add yours.

An Imperial Grunt on the Canadian Military

The Man Who Would Be Khan has an interesting comment on the Canadian military in Robert D. Kaplan’s latest book, Imperial Grunts. From page 106:

In 1985 [Army Lt. Col. Thomas Parker Wilhelm] was sent to the Canadian Land Forces Command and Staff College at Kingston, Ontario, a bastion of British colonial tradition where you wore a tie after six and were given your own napkin ring at mess. “There was a lot of esprit. Everything was deliberate, meticulous, with a fierce sense of a warrior ethic, despite the lack of opportunities Canada had to prove it. I never worked harder writing up op orders. The Canadians didn’t blink; they just kept demanding more detail. I get angry whenever someone belittles the Canadian military.”

The Canadian Land Force Command and Staff College is located at Fort Frontenac, where the Cataraqui River empties into Lake Ontario. Directly across the river sits the Royal Military College. Fort Frontenac was established in 1673, on the site of the first European settlement in Ontario. The current stonework dates back to the 1820s. During the first half of the 19th C Kingston was the planning center for all of Upper Canada.

Fort Frontenac, front and back
Top - Gate of Fort Frontenac, Bottom - Frontenac from rear, Cataraqui River.

The mission of the CLFCSC “educate and train officers, both Regular and Reserve, in the necessary skills to fulfill the appointments of commanders and staffs in units and formation headquarters, within a joint and combined coalition operational environment, throughout the spectrum of conflict.” They have an excellent library filled with Army related books.

One day I am going to sit down and figure out what the equivalent colleges are in the US so the rest of you guys can get an idea of what all this means…

Comments to this entry

lirelou
October 7, 2005
2:12 am
The U.S. equivalent would be the Army Command and General Staff College at Fort Leavenworth, Kansas. There are also a Air Command and Staff College which was at Maxwell AFB, Alabama, a USMC Command and General Staff College at Quantico, VA, and a Naval equivalent somewhere (not sure if its the Naval Postgraduate Institute at Monterrey, CA). The Naval War College, for all yachtees, is at Newport, Rhode Island.
Younghusband
October 7, 2005
3:53 am
I've been told that RMC is the equivalent of Annapolis, rather than West Point, but I am not sure why. What is the difference Lirelou? Just Army vs. Navy or is it deeper than that?
lirelou
October 7, 2005
6:59 am
Other than West Point being the Land Warfare college, and Annapolis being one of three maritime colleges (Naval, Coast Guard, and Merchant Marine in Maryland, Rhose Island, and New York respectively), I don't know. I assume that the Naval Academy teaches land, air, and naval warfare, with the land emphasis being upon the seizure and defence of advanced naval bases, whereas West Point would impart a broader land warfare view. Since Canada now has a unified Armed Forces, I assume that the RMC covers a broad air-land-maritime spectrum much as I presume Annappolis does. Had I had a choice in Royal Military Colleges, I believe I would have preferred Duntroon in Aussie, but the Canadian battalions are every bit as competent as the battalions of the RAR. Both nations have fielded major military forces in time of war. At Kapyong, here in Korea, the combined efforts of the PPCLI and 3RAR convinced the Chinese to drop human wave attacks against western troops in April 1951. I suppose I would have found the Canadian Special Service Force (now extinct?) more akin to U.S. Special Forces, but then the Aussies have that SAS mystique. And in what other Army would you find a regiment whose unofficial song is "I didn't raise my son to be a soldier"? (le 22me RCF) Really beautiful country around Ontario. I begrudge all those lucky enough to be there their beautiful fall and indian-summer weather.
Younghusband
October 7, 2005
5:03 pm
To learn more about the "First Special Service Force":http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Devil%27s_Brigade and it's latter day version "JTF2":http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Canadian_special_forces read the following article entitled "Special Operations Forces - Who Has Seen the Wind? an Historical Overview of Canadian Special Operations":http://www.journal.forces.gc.ca/engraph/Vol5/no3/Special4_e.asp.
Dr. Alfred Russel Wallace
October 8, 2005
4:40 pm
One of the ironies of American History, at least to this aged ex-Brit, is that West Point is both America's most important military college, and also the site of the most infamous act of treachery in the American Revolution. Benedict Arnold, a general in the Continental Army, sent the plans of the fort and how to capture it to British General Sir Henry Clinton in New York. The courier was captured and hung, and Arnold escaped to the British side. It's a fascinating story, which can perhaps be blamed on Jefferson's love of the French!!
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Benedict_Arnold