Entry details

Curzon
Author

Curzon

Date

September 21st, 2005

Tags

,

Comments

11 Comments so far.
Add yours.

An African Chunnel?

Through the 17th and 18th centuries, Britain and France battled for political and commercial supremacy in western Africa.
The 1783 Treaty of Versailles gave Great Britain possession of the Gambia River area, while the French kept most of the inner continent, including the rolling, sandy plains of the western Sabel desert known as the Senegal region. These peculiar borders remained after Senegal became independent in 1960 and The Gambia became independent in 1965.

These peculiar borders cause trouble, as The Gambia blocks the most direct routes between the two halfs of Senegal. This has often caused problems for Senegal, most recently yesterday:

On Tuesday, some Senegalese soldiers were briefly held in Gambia’s capital. The group of soldiers were taking the shortest route between northern Senegal and its southern region, Casamance, which cuts across Gambia – and doing a little shopping on the way. They were detained in Banjul market, and taken off to answer questions about what Senegalese soldiers were doing in Gambia, armed and in uniform, without permission. They had crossed by the Banjul ferry, at the mouth of the Gambia River.

The Trans-Gambia Highway, which runs further inland, has effectively been closed to cross-border traffic for over a month by Senegalese transporters protesting against the sudden doubling of charges to cross the river on the small and unreliable ferry.

President Abdoulaye Wade—a buddy of Mr. Bush—suggested three ways to break the deadlock.

  • Gambia should build a bridge over the river
  • Senegal could operate its own ferry
  • As a last resort, Senegal could tunnel under Gambia – which is only about 35km wide.

Sounds nuts, but there are longer tunnels, including the Chunnel. China has apparently offered to help build it.

Comments to this entry

Alfred Russel Wallace
September 21, 2005
2:04 pm
Surely the issue, "Senegalese soldiers ... in Gambia, armed and in uniform, without permission" doesn't need any of those expensive options - the soldiers should get permission from The Gambia, and "cache" their uniforms and arms in some bonded container that has the approval of the Gambian government for transit.

Africa has many things it could spend money on - a chunnel is surely close to the bottom of the list!
Peter
September 21, 2005
4:17 pm
I would have to agree with Mr. Wallace. The solutions presented just don't seem economically practical considering the problems already facing Africa. Interesting none the less!
cirby
September 21, 2005
8:01 pm
Gambia's GNP is under $500 million. For the price of a 35 km tunnel, Senegal could just offer to buy the place outright for cash.
Curzon
September 21, 2005
8:16 pm
I see your point, i.e. that a tunnel is as absurd as it is expensive, but your premise is based on a faulty theory. A country's GNP does not equal its value or its net worth. If I made $50,000 last year, that does not mean you can "buy" me for that same amount. When people were making a big fuss that Bill Gate's net worth being larger than the GDP of some countries, that was an equally meaningless statement -- yeah, he makes big bucks, but what does that mean in relation to a country's GDP?

Of course, Senegal, with a rather kickass military and 7x the population, could always annex The Gambia...
Eddie
September 21, 2005
11:00 pm
Isn't South Africa the future imperial power of sorts in Africa?
(reading Ralph Peters's "New Glory" section about Africa).

Seriously, a ferry service would be quite feasible. I don't believe either country (even with foreign assistance ala China) has or will soon have the infrastructure to maintain a chunnel.
lirelou
September 22, 2005
12:16 am
Thinking out loud, I wonder what the ethnicity of the Gambian groups is vis-a-vis their neighbors? Perhaps the simple solution is an "anschluss", although simple military liaison a la Mr. Wallace's solution would be far more practical.
Curzon
September 22, 2005
12:28 am
Jesus, "anschluss!?":http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anschluss Too much speaking pagan there for me.

I don't think Senegal, Gambia, Mali et al are even at the level of "ethnicity" -- it remains tribe v.s. tribe. Heck, the Gambia only has a population of 1.1 million yet they have three official languages (not including English, the common language), plus other local dialects.

Eddie -- South Africa may be a regional hegemon if it ever gets its act together (i.e. stops being the crime capital of the world), but Bolivia is closer to the US than the Gambia is to South Africa. Don't expect to see Pretoria solving border disputes in the Sahara anytime soon.
maskull
September 22, 2005
3:53 pm
Ulysses Grant was working to divert the flow of the Mississippi right up until Vicksburg fell.

Re-engineering the flow of the river should suit the Senegalese as well.

Completion of the project would be unnecessary. Once serious work began, The Gambia would capitulate.
cirby
September 23, 2005
7:41 pm
"If I made $50,000 last year, that does not mean you can "buy"Â? me for that same amount."

Yeah,, but for the price of a 35 km tunnel (in the tens of billions, at least), offering someone twenty to thirty times their annual income sure makes for a different argument.

Or, to put it another way, offering the million or so Gambians $10,000 each would be a helluva impetus (about the amount they'd earn in their entire adult lifetimes, at current per capita income there).
J.Kende
September 23, 2005
8:27 pm
Offering handouts of $10,000 each would likely do as much damage as welfare has in other forms at other times. If you want to start personal savings and retirement accounts for them with that money instead, fine. Then at least with the micropayment nature of such a program it will be strengthening their own financial standing for real instead of giving them a one off handout.
sun bin
October 1, 2005
10:27 pm
here is another chunnel, for angola and botswana, the caprivi strip in the NE Namibia for the German colonist ro reach the zambezi river

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Caprivi