Entry details

Curzon
Author

Curzon

Date

August 19th, 2005

Tags

Comments

6 Comments so far.
Add yours.

Kaplan’s Intellectual Honesty

Cunning Realist might appreciate this one:

INTERVIEWER: You write in The Coming Anarchy that, “Africa’s distress will exert a destabilizing influence on the US and that factor and many others will make the US less of a nation than it is today.”

KAPLAN: That was wrong. You write a magazine piece and if it’s relevant for six months you’re happy. If people are arguing about it 12 years later, you’ve kind of achieved your mark. But even in that case in The Coming Anarchy, there are things in there that are just going to be proved dead wrong, and that was one of them. I was a prisoner of the news headlines at the time I was writing, and in this time in mid-1993 there was lots of racial tension for various reasons and no one was owning up to what was about to unfold in many African countries, and I saw a connection where there was none.

From the C-Span interview with Kaplan, 4 April 2005.

Comments to this entry

IJ
August 19, 2005
4:51 pm
>You write in The Coming Anarchy that, "Africa's distress will exert a destabilizing influence on the US and that factor and many others will make the US less of a nation than it is today."Â? KAPLAN: That was wrong.
mark safranski
August 19, 2005
7:29 pm
Very commendable ( and insightful) on Kaplan's part. If his attitude was more widespread among other media heavyweights the MSM would be a lot more useful an interesting. Too many of the celebrity pundits, esp. the TV guys on Sunday morning, let their ego get in the way of their analysis.
Kenneth
August 19, 2005
10:08 pm
Refreshing indeed. That was the only really nebulous part of Kaplan's book: he wasn't really specific about how something confined to a continent already screwed beyond all repair could pertain to us, or do so in a manner we could not counter.
Chief Wiggum
August 19, 2005
10:55 pm
As I recall in _Coming Anarchy_ Kaplan also said the Palestinian-Israeli conflict was over (this was after the signing of the Oslo accords). Misteaks of this kind are made when you assume that both parties are dealing in good faith.
Kenneth
August 20, 2005
2:51 am
I think it was mentioned in passing in the first essay. He didn't go into any detail about it.
ComingAnarchy.com » Blog Archive » C’est magnifique, mais ce n’est pas la guerre (yet)
November 7, 2005
2:42 am
[...] Kaplan later said his dire predictions about racial clashes in the United States were wrong, but the concept holds true: societies that do not properly integrate minorities and immigrants socially and economically will result in the disenfranchised resenting the society they live in. They will lash out, often in bursts of coordinated violence. Europe has a serious problem on its hand that it must figure out by itself. [...]