Entry details

Curzon
Author

Curzon

Date

July 20th, 2005

Tags

Comments

13 Comments so far.
Add yours.

Avast!

Sea piracy drops worldwide
Iraq, Somalia increasingly dangerous, watchdog warns

The number of pirate attacks worldwide hit a six-year low in the first half of 2005, but Iraq and Somalia emerged as increasingly perilous hotspots for commercial ships, a maritime watchdog said Wednesday.

Globally, 127 vessels were attacked from January to June, a 30 percent drop from 182 cases in the same period last year, the International Maritime Bureau said in a report released by its piracy watch center in Kuala Lumpur.

It was the lowest first-half figure since 1999, the British-based bureau reported.

Funny, I remember reading about how piracy in the Malacca Straits between Singapore, Malaysia, and Indonesia was becoming a real problem… so much so that Japan was deploying ships to the region.

Several countries reported fewer attacks, including Indonesia, Nigeria, Venezuela, Ghana, the Philippines, Malaysia, Thailand, Bangladesh, Brazil, Cameroon, Colombia, Ecuador, Mauritania, Senegal and Sierra Leone. No seafarers have been killed by pirates so far in 2005 compared to 30 by this time last year, the report said. Thirteen crew were injured, down from 44 in the first six months of 2004.

But the International Maritime Bureau warned of “a new and worrying trend” of armed robberies in Iraqi waters, noting that four “serious incidents” were reported there between April and June, despite the presence of U.S.-led coalition naval ships in the area. Before this year, “attacks in and around Iraq were almost nonexistent,” the bureau noted. It did not give details on why Iraqi waters have become more dangerous.

Security also worsened dramatically off Somalia’s east coast, where bandits with guns and grenades attacked eight vessels and sometimes seized hostages for ransom. Only one attack occurred in Somalia between January and June last year. “Pirates operating off Somalia have become increasingly audacious,” bureau Director Pottengal Mukundan said. “Their demands for ransom are higher than ever before and negotiations for the release of the vessel and crew can become difficult and prolonged.” Ships not making scheduled calls on Somalian ports should remain at least 80 kilometers (50 miles) or “as far away as practical” from the east coast of the country, which is beset by political problems and poor law enforcement, the report said.

Indonesia’s waters remained the world’s most pirate-infested, though the number of attacks across the country’s sprawling archipelago so far this year slipped to 42—one-third of the worldwide total—compared to 50 in the first half of 2004.

That tally did not include attacks in the Malacca Strait, the busy shipping lane that separates Indonesia’s Sumatra island, Singapore and peninsular Malaysia. The strait was also safer, with eight attacks so far this year compared to 20 in the same timeframe in 2004, the bureau said, partly because pirates were deterred by a large naval presence after the December 26 tsunami.

The truth comes out…

The International Maritime Bureau indicated it opposes shipping firms using private security forces to escort commercial vessels through the strait, saying such moves “will raise the level of arms used by both sides and make these waters an even more dangerous place.”

What? We’re not talking about pirates here. We’re talking about private security protecting the lifelines of the global economy from lawless marauders. If the regional governments can’t or won’t provide the security—which in international waters, they may not feel they have the responsibility to do—how can it be a bad thing to increase legitimate security?

Comments to this entry

Kenneth
July 20, 2005
4:15 pm
_...private security protecting the lifelines of the global economy..._

Another victory for the market.
Younghusband
July 20, 2005
5:01 pm
I have been meaning to post on maritime piracy for some time now. It is funny the reaction you get when you talk about pirates or mercenaries in the present tense, and people are like "Wha..!? They don't exist any more do they?"

As far as the private security issue is concerned, according to maritime law, who is legally allowed to patrol international waters? If you can hire security guards to protect your store, why can't you hire them to protect your shipping vessel?

And what is the IMB's alternative? "Talk" to the pirates? Give them a "time out"? Somehow I don't think if you ignore this problem that it will go away.
Nathan
July 20, 2005
7:28 pm
We're not talking about pirates here. We're talking about private security protecting the lifelines of the global economy from lawless marauders.

Curzon... Curzon... Curzon...

What we should be talking about here is the connection between the number of pirates and global temperature change. (About the sixth paragraph down)
Chief Wiggum
July 20, 2005
11:24 pm
_The International Maritime Bureau indicated it opposes shipping firms using private security forces to escort commercial vessels through the strait, saying such moves "will raise the level of arms used by both sides and make these waters an even more dangerous place."Â?_

Absolutely right! The presence of police will only create more crime and mayhem. What is needed are human shields.
Curzon
July 21, 2005
12:30 am
Nathan, you were right!

Dan
July 21, 2005
2:41 am
We could end the firewall of naval protection, and go entirely for self-protecting vessells...

But such is extremism. A healthy computer network has a perimeter firewall, sub-net firewalls, and individual anti-malware protection. If my college network can have a fireall AND have software on every computers, it makes just as much sense to have the US Navy protect shipping lanes AND encourage every vessel to be armed.
heirabbit
July 21, 2005
11:02 am
Looks like the IMB has never see Casablanca. That, or they're trying to push counterproductive policies as a method of bolstering their bureaucratic status.
Eddie
July 21, 2005
12:48 pm
The whole study is bunk. Probably half of the pirate attacks that happen are never reported by the victim's company, because it could become a public relations or insurance problem. Add in the fact they didn't include the attacks in the Straits, and you have a flawed study that becomes even more uncredible by the author's pushing an unrealistic agenda (i.e. opposing the use of private security forces) onto the reader.
There is a rich opportunity for the Indian, US, Singapore, Australian and regional navies to work together to greatly reduce pirate assaults in the Straits region, if only the sales pitch can be packaged and presented in a sensible manner that doesn't put off the Indonesians or Malaysians.
Btw with Somalia, we should be dispatching more naval vessels to those waters (as well as Marines from Djibouti) to combat these pirates, as they are likely aiding and abbetting the various warlords and gangs with Al-Qaeda ties.
tdaxp
July 22, 2005
3:50 am
Have You Read Your Daily Blogosphere?

Freedom House Expo on North Korea   Media Roundup [Instapundit Link] Thanks to Us, Peace Is Not at Hand LiNK Protest at the South Korean Embassy Q&A with Sharansky, Kang Chol-Hwan, and Sen. Sam Brownback Sharansky Speech General Observati...
Dan
July 31, 2005
4:20 pm
John Robb has picked up on the theme

http://globalguerrillas.typepad.com/johnrobb/2005/07/private_naviesm.html
ComingAnarchy.com » Blog Archive » Surrender or starve
August 12, 2005
7:30 pm
[...] Pirates seized a UN-chartered ship carrying tsunami aid to Somalia. The ship was carrying 850 tons of rice for people in central Somalia. We’ve seen this kind of activity before, and we have previously discussed the responsibilities of nations in combating piracy. I don’t know what else to say… Leave a Reply [...]
ComingAnarchy.com » Blog Archive » Avast!
January 23, 2006
9:02 am
[...] Surrender or starveMore on PiracyAvast!Democracy is Overrated [...]
ComingAnarchy.com » Blog Archive » Mapping the Gap Part III by Chirol
March 13, 2006
10:11 pm
[...] Keep in mind this area an be physical such as land, water or air or nonphysical such as cyberspace, financial transactions, and even an individuals mind. There are several subcategories of ungoverned area: [...]