Entry details

Younghusband
Author

Younghusband

Date

July 15th, 2005

Tags

, ,

Comments

7 Comments so far.
Add yours.

“Our job is to be able to kill people”

JTF2Following up on Nathan’s recent comments regarding Canada’s commitments in Afghanistan Canada’s top soldier Gen. Rick Hillier has confirmed that Joint Task Force 2, Canada’s secretive SpecOps unit, will be on the hunt for al Qaeda and Taliban remnantsin Afghanistan. He was quoted as saying:

We’re not the public service of Canada, we’re not just another department. We are the Canadian Forces, and our job is to be able to kill people.

The Canadian Forces are a small but tough bunch. There are more people in the Toronto Police Department than in the whole CF, and these guys are charged with defending the world’s second largest country at home and abroad with minimal funds and public support.

I recently interviewed a group of Princess Patricia’s Canadian Light Infantry based out of Edmonton doing basic mountain ops training in the rugged wilderness near my town. Unlike larger armies (ie. the US) who have officers whose only job is to train soldiers, the CF Officers have to fulfill this obligation above and beyond their regular occupation. One officer in fact told me that many soldiers actually have 6 or 8 jobs. They didn’t even have drivers to ship them out here to the Rockies, and after a hard week which included a 36 hour straight tactical training op, they had to load up in their trucks and drive the 8 hours home.

I have nothing but respect for any professional, volunteer soldier. But being one in Canada these days is extra-tough, and deserving of even more esteem in my humble opinion.

Comments to this entry

Chirol
July 16, 2005
12:30 pm
Excellent. Always interesting to hear more about Canada's military and its contributions to international operations. You hear so little about them!
Curzon
July 17, 2005
6:34 am
Especially when Sir Francis Younghusband will have a first-hand view in a few short weeks!
GI Korea
July 19, 2005
11:12 am
You are right, all professional soldiers deserve respect but the things you describe the Canadian military doing, we do all the time in the US Army. We all are tasked with 6-8 jobs. So your assertion that US military officers' only responsibility is to train soldiers is incorrect. Plus the Canadians did tactical training for 36 hours, we do tactical non-stop training at the National Training Center for one month straight then from there we get shipped to do one year tours to both Iraq, Afghanistan, Korea, and where ever else the world needs us. Being a veteran of the Iraq war and multiple tours in Korea, Edmonton doesn't sound too bad to me.
Younghusband
July 19, 2005
4:05 pm
GI Korea, good to hear from someone with experience.

The mountain ops course was one week long. During the course they had a 36hr _straight_, meaning no sleep, tactical exercise. I am sorry for the confusion.

The next day they had to drive home. I know that in the Korean Military they have "drivers," but mind you that is an army full of civilians. I am sure the US military does all kinds of insane training and stuff, but the issue at hand is occupations and tasking. I know this is one of the big complaints of CF Forces, who spend a lot of time over the border doing work with their American counterparts. The CF here get so little funding, and look over the border with green eyes.
lirelou
July 20, 2005
8:34 am
As long as we have Yanks and Canuks discussing the Canadian Forces, I might propose that on 5 December you all raise a glass to "Menton Day" On 5 December 1944, at Menton, France, the Americans and Canadians who had composed the First Special Service Force split off into national contingents. The Canadians became the 2nd Can Para Bat, and the Americans the 474th Infantry (destined for Norway). Whatever our disagreements, our fathers formed one hell of a combined fighting force. When the Canadian Special Service Force was in existence, the occasion was marked in Petawawa and Fort Bragg on consecutive years, with the American Special Forces serving as hosts when the Canadiens travelled down to Fort Bragg.

Vive le 22me!
ComingAnarchy.com » Blog Archive » Parrish the thought
July 28, 2005
5:58 pm
[...] Carolyn Parrish is at it again. The former Liberal MP was booted from caucus last year for calling Americans bastards and President George Bush a moron all within earshot of the press core. Now she is making waves by attacking Canadian Forces General Rick Hillier, Chief of the Defence Staff, calling him “truly barbaric” and imploring Defense Minister Bill Graham to “muzzle the beast.” This is in reaction to Gen. Hillier’s remarks regarding the recent CF deployment in Afghanistan (remember the “Our job is to be able to kill people” quote?). [...]
ComingAnarchy.com » Blog Archive » Canada Command
August 19, 2005
6:23 pm
[...] I have written about the Canadian military before but I would just like to point out a brilliant comment by The Economist regarding the recent changes in the attitude of the military (see the CDS’s comments here): The rise to senior commands of three generals with experience of irregular warfare in Afghanistan and the Middle East has set in motion a revolution in Canadian military thinking. General Rick Hillier, the new chief of defence staff, once headed the multinational ISAF force in Kabul; his chief of strategic planning, Andrew Leslie also served there; while Major-General Walter Natynczyk, who is implementing the reforms, is fresh from a year with American troops in Iraq. He and General Hillier have also both served as deputy commander of the US Third Armoured Corps in Texas. [...]