The African-American chat-show host announced during a recent visit to South Africa that she had had a DNA test that had shown her to be a Zulu.She also told South Africans she felt “at home” in the country. “I went in search of my roots and had my DNA tested, and I am a Zulu,” Ms Winfrey said at a seminar in Johannesburg last week. Professor Himla Soodyall of South Africa’s National Health Laboratory Service said it was likely that Oprah Winfrey would have taken a mitochondrial DNA test.
Problem is, that doesn’t really mean much of anything in regards to, say, the reality of Zulu history, which began as just one of many tribes in South Africa in the 18th century. It’s sort of like me saying that I could genetically link my ancestry to American colonists in North Carolina, when in fact 300-400 years ago is not enough to give any real reliability.
There is not much to distinguish between various linguistic groups, particularly the different language groups spoken in southern Africa, because they have diversified more recently – perhaps within the past 1,000-1,500 years – than genetic differences which have been evolving in our species for about 150,000 years ago,” she said. This could, however, explain how Ms Winfrey’s DNA matched with a sample from a Zulu person, even though most African-Americans have ancestors who have been traced to west Africa as a consequence of the slave trade. According to most historical accounts, the Zulu nation was consolidated only after the departure of slaves from west Africa to the Americas.
Finally, considering Ms. Winfrey’s success and wealth, I really, really wonder how true this is:
“I’m crazy about the South African accent,” she said. “I wish I had been born here.”

Comments to this entry
Mike
June 16, 2005
12:37 am
Nathan
June 16, 2005
4:36 am
You can do the same thing with genetic markers on the Y-Chromosome. Actually, Spencer Wells has an interesting book and documentary about this in which he tracks human migration this way. He mentions doing tests with a handful of men in the UK of different ethnic backgrounds. One of them, a Caribbean, ended up having European rather than African markers on his Y chromosome. He was apparently devastated to learn that despite having only black living relatives, he was a direct descendant of a white man. (His family had some kind of proud Zulu warrior myth or something.) The testing can tell us interesting things about our ancestors (well, in cases like mDNA or Y chromosome markers, one ancestor), but doesn't really capture genetically who we are. Hell, I'd say genes are a pretty bad foundation for one's identity period.
BTW, I'm totally 1/64 Cherokee (or Chickasaw, but who's paying attention) so, you know, that's totally who I am and stuff. (Though, we do like to point out we're more Native American than Ward Churchill.)
Dave Schuler
June 16, 2005
2:53 pm
Dusty
June 16, 2005
3:16 pm
But it is good to keep in mind a couple of things about this. One is that her desire to know wasn't based on any serious scientific interest in her genealogy or she would have acknowledged that Zulu is only part of her genealogy.
The other is that, and now I'm considering the last part of your post, Curzon, but from a different angle, Ms. Winfrey is using it as useful fodder for self-promotion. I doubt very much that she meant she likes the accent patterns of the Zulu language that *we hear so often on television and at the movies.* And her nostalgic-like wish to have been born in South Africa, so she could be South African, language and all, is what is called connecting. At least she did it much better and more gracefully than Hillary did in New Zealand and she did it without lying.
But I'll grant Ms. Winfrey's fantasy as being a whimsy similar to my sometimes thought about having been born a Viking so I could have worn furry vests to look bigger than I am and horned caps so people would run at the site of me (for reasons different than they do now.) The difference between her whimsy and mine is her's will likely be profitable. Ms. Winfrey has begun another meme for her show, inspired her followers to find their roots and also connected with them in another way, and possibly upped viewer share for the show as a result. That's show business and she is good at it.
Sara
July 11, 2005
12:24 pm
Mageba
July 30, 2005
1:24 pm
Softshade
August 18, 2005
9:15 pm
ssmith
September 14, 2005
6:37 pm
The new craze of mapping ones genealogy is spreading through the white community like wild fire and now spawns many new ways for others to make money off them. Many Black people in the Diaspora will or cannot be so lucky. We may find incomplete histories of our lineage and therefore continue to feed the great disconnect. This is something many of us have been successful in combating.
As it seems to me no one wants to rush to the bottom, which is where most in this world place Black people. As one of those proud Black people I think if such a test were available White people around the world should worry more as they will then be very sure that the cradle of mankind was Africa and we are all in fact Black people.
"Human rights first and the rest will follow!"