Last Friday, Curzon, in his role as “Adjunct Professor” of political science, brought in about 25 students to New York City. Actually, the two TAs organized the logistics and Professor Curzon just sat back and enjoyed the trip, the highlight of which was a tour of the United Nations.
(Enough of the third-person narrative.) This is my fourth semester of teaching and my second trip to the UN with my students. Once again, I rolled my eyes as I watched the tour guide talk about all the alleged good the UN has done, and chuckled to myself as the dreamy-eyed undergraduates chattered on about the glories of world government. Afterwards, when the kids went off on their own to Broadway shows, karaoke bars and who knows what else, I met a friend living in the city who I hadn’t seen in more than six years for a meal and drinks. Both of us have become significantly more conservative from where we were six years ago. Upon hearing of my tour, he quipped that any trip he made to the UN would be with “a truckload of fertilizer.”
I’m not quite that right-wing, but I understand his sentiments. The UN is by-and-large a waste of resources, and the multi-layered bureaucracy has perfected the art of doing more harm than good when it comes to peace and world order. But despite my cynicism, credit should be given where credit is due: the UN’s role in syncronizing traffic lights, a small but nonetheless excellent service that has probably saved millions of lives over the past sixty years.
The first traffic light appeared in the United Kingdom in the late 1860s (!), and by World War I they could be found across the United States, Europe, Japan, China, and parts of Latin America. But there was no syncronization of color, style, or timing—a traffic light in France could be quite different from a traffic light in Belgium, leading to all sorts of accidents. The League of Nations tried to cope with the problem of traffic safety shortly after it was formed in 1919, with some results. But it was the UN’s Conference on Road and Motor Traffic in 1949 that syncronized traffic lights worldwide (the UN also created zebra crossings).
When it comes to dealing with thugs and tyrants like Hussein and Kim Gone Ill, I’d rather the UN just sit down and shut up. But when it comes to the sundry details of living in a globalized world economy, we should keep in mind that no matter what complaints we may have about the UN, it nonetheless has a necessary role that even an old cynic like myself has to recognize.
- BROWSE / IN TIMELINE
- « The would-be king steps down
- » Letter of Apology
COMMENTS / 10 COMMENTS
Liberals Against Terrorism added these pithy words on Feb 25 05 at 5:48 pmExciting New Logo Discussion!
Young Husband of Coming Anarchy fame has kindly offered to design a new logo for us here. His own blog is one of the best looking sites around, so be sure to check it out in all of its beauty. He’s doing this
ComingAnarchy.com » Blog Archive » Happy Birthday To Us! added these pithy words on Sep 30 05 at 3:38 pm[...] Lord George Nathaniel CURZON Curzon’s New Map: What East Asian geopolitics is really about. A big “FU” to Greece: The US dishes out appropriate payback to an ally and an opponent. The State of 21st Century Media: The BBC gives terrorists a free pass while needling US troops at every turn. Traffic Lights: Thank the UN: Stop global government mission creep! This is what the UN can do. Bad Democracies, Good Dictatorships: Alas, the world isn’t as simple as good democrats and bad dictators. The Curzon Line: a little piece of history… The Argument, Reloaded: Defending Japan against protests and criticism from its neighbors. Curzon and the TEMPLE OF DOOM: Be warned, this is not for the faint of heart. Sanctions Suck: A call for engagement or invasion. Coming Anarchy in Nepal: A fatalistic take on the current situation in the Himalayan kingdom. [...]
Mutantfrog added these pithy words on 23 Feb 05 at 7:44 amThe UN has a major role in a lot of important but oft-overlooked treaties, standards, agreements. One good example (especially for your law student self!) is the “United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods,” or CISG for short. In sharp contrast to the vague notions of ‘international law’ that people mumble about when one country tries to invade another, the CISG is a legally binding code for international commerce which is actually used for a decent portion of international traffic in goods. There are plenty of other things on this level where the UN has actually managed to get something done. Now, when the security council gets involved it tends to get into a lot of bullshit, but there are good things going on over there.
Curzon added these pithy words on 23 Feb 05 at 11:49 amThe CISG is so pointless that it is less than one full day in the law school course “International Business Transactions” that I am currently taking. And, in my own limited experience in the legal practice of actual transnational agreements, I have never seen the CISG mentioned as a legally binding document. Countries agree to it as a statement of guiding principles and little more. Although I suppose it might have a purpose in the less-civilized areas of the world where business customs are archaic, counterproductive, or just plain weird that nothing in the one of the home jurisdictions is compatible with the other side.
Dan added these pithy words on 23 Feb 05 at 12:56 pmGreat minds think alike!
Don’t write off the UN’s harm so easily. It may be doing good by doing ill. In Kosovo and other places it runs into the ground, it sends a stern message to dysfunctional regimes: if you act so badly that we get involved, you will have to live under us.
Dan added these pithy words on 23 Feb 05 at 12:57 pmDarn it. Link was broken. Maybe ?. If this doesn’t work I give up ;)
Younghusband added these pithy words on 23 Feb 05 at 1:34 pmFirst link fixed. Don’t forget your a href=” !! Or better yet just do it in Textile by putting the link text between double quotes, followed by a colon and the URL:
Read “this link” :http://www.blah-blah.com
(minus the space between the second quotes and colon)
Younghusband added these pithy words on 23 Feb 05 at 3:53 pmThanks, but I would rather be your all Canadian hero… Captain Canuck maybe?
Dan added these pithy words on 23 Feb 05 at 8:43 pmWell, at least you’re not Dutch.
I’ll be in the cold, cold ground before I honor a Dutchman.
